- Posts
- 33,601
- Location
- North Shropshire
When you consider the price of going to a garage for a diagnostic report, it doesn't take many trips before things add up. Once you have it, you'll not look back. It's a great thing to have
P38A Losing codes if battery goes flat
- Thread starter rayvee
- Start date
This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.
I can't work out if the original question got answered or not, but yes, if the battery goes flat while connected then it can:
i. desynch the key (especially if the remote button was pressed with the car battery disconnected/flat) it's usually simple to resynch if the key fob is not damaged, and the drivers door lock is fully functioning, although you need to clear any immobilisation first. You are most likely stuffed if the BeCM has been changed and not programmed properly since it contains lockset coding
ii. the engine will most likely be immobilised. It may be remobilised by putting the key in the ignition (if the induction coil works still it will trigger the fob to disarm the immobiliser). Or it may need the EKA - this can be input via the door lock (though you are probably stuffed if the BeCM has been changed - it contains the EKA). LR will give you the EKA from the original BeCM FoC - which will only help if it was reprogrammed properly
iii. BeCM to Thor coding - above my pay-grade as I have the earlier GEMS, which will automatically relearn the code when the diagnostics is used. I am told that with Thor you will have to go into the ECM pick up the code, and then type it back into the BeCM, but that's second hand info.
If Thor cranks but doesn't fire then iii. is a distinct possibility and depending on what diagnostics the garage has they may/ may not be able to fix it.
If the battery was disconnected "properly" ie unlock, pop the hood, undo the negative. then more than likely nothing loses synch (never has on my GEMS, at least)
Did they really change the BeCM? If they had I wd have thought you'd have even more problems than this, unless it was coded properly. I'd be asking for the original BeCM back i. as proof they changed it, but ii. because you're probably better off reverting to the original one. If the power board in the original BeCM was playing up it can be swapped with another BeCM of the same vintage without recoding the BeCM.
Who are these jokers?
i. desynch the key (especially if the remote button was pressed with the car battery disconnected/flat) it's usually simple to resynch if the key fob is not damaged, and the drivers door lock is fully functioning, although you need to clear any immobilisation first. You are most likely stuffed if the BeCM has been changed and not programmed properly since it contains lockset coding
ii. the engine will most likely be immobilised. It may be remobilised by putting the key in the ignition (if the induction coil works still it will trigger the fob to disarm the immobiliser). Or it may need the EKA - this can be input via the door lock (though you are probably stuffed if the BeCM has been changed - it contains the EKA). LR will give you the EKA from the original BeCM FoC - which will only help if it was reprogrammed properly
iii. BeCM to Thor coding - above my pay-grade as I have the earlier GEMS, which will automatically relearn the code when the diagnostics is used. I am told that with Thor you will have to go into the ECM pick up the code, and then type it back into the BeCM, but that's second hand info.
If Thor cranks but doesn't fire then iii. is a distinct possibility and depending on what diagnostics the garage has they may/ may not be able to fix it.
If the battery was disconnected "properly" ie unlock, pop the hood, undo the negative. then more than likely nothing loses synch (never has on my GEMS, at least)
Did they really change the BeCM? If they had I wd have thought you'd have even more problems than this, unless it was coded properly. I'd be asking for the original BeCM back i. as proof they changed it, but ii. because you're probably better off reverting to the original one. If the power board in the original BeCM was playing up it can be swapped with another BeCM of the same vintage without recoding the BeCM.
Who are these jokers?
Last edited:
If you plan on keeping the car diagnostics is a good investment, end of story. Especially if you can do a bit of spanner work, it would not need to go to the garage. Remember it covers a lot more than just BECM.
Now to buy diagnostics personally todo the level of work “your garage” has claimed is very expensive. I would think highly unlikely your garage have that level of diagnostics.
It’s more likely they sent yours off and either had it repaired or info put on a secondhand 1. How much did they charge for the BECM itself not including labour?
There are a few cases where your £400 (+/- cost) diagnostics will not be able to help, and you will have to seek professional help, but as I said earlier a well kept car, good personal diagnostics is a good tool for the toolbox. There is also a very strong second hand market for resale.
Now you may scan this forum and say well there are so manyBECM problems, I am afraid that is the nature of forums mostly fixing problems. The biggest majority on here don’t have BECM problems.
in short.
Don’t worry about a flat battery if the rest is good and diagnostics is a good investment. Enjoy the bloody thing
J
- Posts
- 19,297
- Location
- Buckinghamshire, UK. ('95 DT)
In short, almost certainly no.
Most of the time no codes needed at all. Procedure to sync the fobs is in the manual and just requires turning the key and pressing the fob button. Occasionally the EKA code needs entering using the key. Very rarely the EMS code goes out of sync but usually after RF interference or some weird set of circumstances. Diag is needed for that.
- Posts
- 12,634
- Location
- Sud ouest France !
Hopefully it's a misunderstanding between yourself and the garage, they aren't taking the preverbial and you haven't mistaken what they've said. It is amazing how many clients can agree and understand what your saying on the day and then completely forget or even deny anything you've explained.. Not all but....
RangeRoller dt
Well-Sprung Member
- Posts
- 14,393
- Location
- Trapped inside my head @ LZ asylum
try putting new batteries in the fob
tomcat59alan
Well-Known Member
- Posts
- 18,611
- Location
- wirral and triquivijate
Good point.
rayvee
Member
- Posts
- 10
- Location
- North West
Thanks all again,
I was told that the BeCM had been replaced , the part cost £450 and was guaranteed for 2 years. I was also told that if the battery goes flat when in the car It "might" need the codes reinputting. Nothing to do with the radio, key fob or EKA. The garage is a so called specialist on Land Rovers. The story they gave me for having to wait 8 months was that Autologic had taken their old diagnostics (that had P38 codes) and given them a new one that didn't include the P38. They eventually had to borrow kit from another garage as they didn't want to spend what Autologic wanted for replacement. I like the idea of a solar panel charger. Any recommendations. I also like the thought of my own diagnostics but worry I would still need to involve a garage(but a different one!)
I think the P38 is brilliant and would love to keep it but it will have to be more reliable(wife would get rid). Apparently computer routers can affect the battery.
I was told that the BeCM had been replaced , the part cost £450 and was guaranteed for 2 years. I was also told that if the battery goes flat when in the car It "might" need the codes reinputting. Nothing to do with the radio, key fob or EKA. The garage is a so called specialist on Land Rovers. The story they gave me for having to wait 8 months was that Autologic had taken their old diagnostics (that had P38 codes) and given them a new one that didn't include the P38. They eventually had to borrow kit from another garage as they didn't want to spend what Autologic wanted for replacement. I like the idea of a solar panel charger. Any recommendations. I also like the thought of my own diagnostics but worry I would still need to involve a garage(but a different one!)
I think the P38 is brilliant and would love to keep it but it will have to be more reliable(wife would get rid). Apparently computer routers can affect the battery.
tomcat59alan
Well-Known Member
- Posts
- 18,611
- Location
- wirral and triquivijate
Your RF receiver can pick up spurious signals from WiFi,wireless door chimes,weather stations etc.there was a case of a cafe in Bowness affecting parked cars because the waitress was using a wireless order module that transmitted to the kitchen.these signals wake up the becm and it thinks its being stolen so relocks the car. This can happen regularly and lead to burnt out locks and a flat battery. I had my car disabled in Carlisle once because of a department stores WiFi. There are many sites around the country known to the breakdown services where cars were disabled until towed away from the area.
Rubbish don’t worry.
Did I not say they wouldn’t have paid for it
and as far as I know Auto logic cannot reprogram a secondhand BECM. Which is what you got. Ask them for the EKA code.As for all the extra WiFi squiggly things flying around, yes it seems too be a problem and is all to do with the RF receiver frequency. For right now the best course of action seems to be to unplug the antenna to said unit. You just need to be very close to the car to unlock.
There are fixes for this but don’t worry about them right now
. Same with charging depending on where you park the car and how often you use it.Search on here for diagnostics there has been many discussions about it.
Take the good wife out and float her about in a great car she will soon love it. Some say “oh it’s too big”
My M wouldn’t drive anything she doesn’t feel safe inside.J
tomcat59alan
Well-Known Member
- Posts
- 18,611
- Location
- wirral and triquivijate
To unplug the antenna remove the drivers side parcel shelf support panel,three plastic clips and one Phillips screw.You will see the rf receiver by the rear seat release button.unplug the blue wire.job done.And you cannot use the weather as an excuse not to do it,you can sit in the boot all cosy..when the clips and screw are removed it lifts upwards out of three spring clips by the window.Rubbish don’t worry.
Did I not say they wouldn’t have paid for it
As for all the extra WiFi squiggly things flying around, yes it seems too be a problem and is all to do with the RF receiver frequency. For right now the best course of action seems to be to unplug the antenna to said unit. You just need to be very close to the car to unlock.
There are fixes for this but don’t worry about them right now
Search on here for diagnostics there has been many discussions about it.
Take the good wife out and float her about in a great car she will soon love it. Some say “oh it’s too big”
J
Last edited:
brianp38dse
Well-Known Member
- Posts
- 20,067
- Location
- heathrow
tomcat59alan
Well-Known Member
- Posts
- 18,611
- Location
- wirral and triquivijate
You may be right Brian, how's things with you? I had a telephone consultation on Wednesday and the specialist said I need a CT scan,just had a phone call from the hospital asking could i make it Sunday and what time would be best for me.Looks like your memory's getting better
keep up the good work.
Thought I would be waiting for months.
- Posts
- 19,297
- Location
- Buckinghamshire, UK. ('95 DT)
Don't think Autologic will touch BECM. Testbook would or Nanocom for some stuff but other than that you're looking at a Faultmate.
brianp38dse
Well-Known Member
- Posts
- 20,067
- Location
- heathrow
You may be right Brian, how's things with you? I had a telephone consultation on Wednesday and the specialist said I need a CT scan,just had a phone call from the hospital asking could i make it Sunday and what time would be best for me.
I am ok thanks but have been told by letter that I am to stay at home again as clinically extremely vonerable to this virus, great being self employed
Glid you seam to be getting back to your old self
tomcat59alan
Well-Known Member
- Posts
- 18,611
- Location
- wirral and triquivijate
Good luck mate,it cannot last forever, ...can it ?I am ok thanks but have been told by letter that I am to stay at home again as clinically extremely vonerable to this virus, great being self employed
Glid you seam to be getting back to your old self
- Posts
- 19,297
- Location
- Buckinghamshire, UK. ('95 DT)
I am ok thanks but have been told by letter that I am to stay at home again as clinically extremely vonerable to this virus, great being self employed
Glid you seam to be getting back to your old self
Transplant status? I could do with a few weeks furloughed. Swap?!
- Posts
- 19,297
- Location
- Buckinghamshire, UK. ('95 DT)
Good luck mate,it cannot last forever, ...can it ?
I think by the time Easter next year has passed we'll be on top of it and seriously winning. Couple of wobbles over the winter, a bit of time to get the Oxford vaccine out and get cases down and by May we'll be looking forward to an ice-cream summer.
tomcat59alan
Well-Known Member
- Posts
- 18,611
- Location
- wirral and triquivijate
Hope your right mate, should have locked the country down completely in February and it would all a memory now,but hindsight is a wonderful thing.
Last edited:
brianp38dse
Well-Known Member
- Posts
- 20,067
- Location
- heathrow
Yes because of the transplants, i dont know why it makes me a risk but they say i am so bow down to them as they know best
and you would not want my furlough money
