P38A Last post

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.
Mark Piercy said:
Where did you get that idea from?? :eek:
You've been watching them scary films again... Or is it just eastenders :p
Click to expand...
Don’t watch TV

When you come home and there’s a stack of emulsion in the hallway ....

5271DC21-41AC-4FEB-B21C-A91F8751592F.jpeg
 
romanrob said:
Thanks. Personally I don't think I have ever been able to change the immob settings and eka enabled settings while the engine is in an immobilised state - and I've tried on 3 immobilised cars in the last few months (all GEMS era, and >v36 BeCM) - I got them all moving, but by virtue of an EKA code, ultimately. It would help me and I dare say others if you could maybe post a video of how you do it starting from EKA enabled/ setting the alarm and triggering it (pull the sill button) and then showing how you get the eka disabled option to stick long enough to start the car.
Click to expand...

What does tumble-weed sound like?

Pretty sure my GEMS does exactly the opposite of what the appraisal Nano/ diesel combo is doing. If you try and DISable EKA and Immmobiliser after the alarm is tripped they will get rolled back to ENabled. Nanocom gives you confirmation of success, blah, blah but if you close the session and return the fields are ENabled once again. So then you're still left with other 3 tools to get going - key, remote & EKA. I'll go out on a limb, and say that changing these settings to disabled in an alarmed state can't be done by nanocom, and can't magically start a 4.6 GEMS.

Not sure it really matters anyway - if you have a nanocom then you have a means to enter the EKA which is surely the logical option, and probably not worth having flamed someone over, especially given that no-one else can replicate what you have seen
 
Last edited:
romanrob said:
What does tumble-weed sound like?

Pretty sure my GEMS does exactly the opposite of what the appraisal Nano/ diesel combo is doing. If you try and DISable EKA and Immmobiliser after the alarm is tripped they will get rolled back to ENabled. Nanocom gives you confirmation of success, blah, blah but if you close the session and return the fields are ENabled once again. So then you're still left with other 3 tools to get going - key, remote & EKA. I'll go out on a limb, and say that changing these settings to disabled in an alarmed state can't be done by nanocom, and can't magically start a 4.6 GEMS.

Not sure it really matters anyway - if you have a nanocom then you have a means to enter the EKA which is surely the logical option, and probably not worth having flamed someone over, especially given that no-one else can replicate what you have seen
Click to expand...
The immobilisation can be disabled whilst active, end of story.
 
I believe that you though you did it, as you seem very sure. Since you previously said it was when you first got the nanocom then I guess you may have forgotten what else you were changing in the background as you were probably only just figuring it out at the time. I can tell you it doesn't work on GEMS - and I've tried several times to replicate your claim. I guess it's not impossible that you have some prototype software on your nano - what version are you running?
 
romanrob said:
I believe that you though you did it, as you seem very sure. Since you previously said it was when you first got the nanocom then I guess you may have forgotten what else you were changing in the background as you were probably only just figuring it out at the time. I can tell you it doesn't work on GEMS - and I've tried several times to replicate your claim. I guess it's not impossible that you have some prototype software on your nano - what version are you running?
Click to expand...
I HAVE DONE IT SEVERAL TIMES, what part of that statement do you not understand?
 
Is the below not an accurate summary of what you are saying, then? Are you sure you don't have some extra functionality on your nano that didn't make it to the production version? I'm struggling to understand where the mismatch is, but maybe I've misunderstood what you're actually claiming to have done?

Goto P38 > EDC > then click right hand green arrow until you see BECM. Click on BECM, then settings, then Alarm. Top of first page is immobiliser that will need setting disabled. Click on right hand green arrow until you see EKA that willneed setting disabled. You can't do anything on emulator but will be able to when plugged into car. To put BECM into diagnostic mode Leave ignition OFF. Plug Nanocom in wait until it loads then goto BECM as above. After a few seconds dash message will read Diagnostic mode. Follow above then when immobiliser and EKA have been set disabled, go back one page by pressing red cross and select write settings. wait for Nanocom to do it's thing. Switch Nanocom off. Switch ignition on message should go and car will start. DO NOT start car with Nanocom on. Always switch it off before operating starter
 
Last edited:
romanrob said:
Is the below not an accurate summary of what you are saying, then? Are you sure you don't have some extra functionality on your nano that didn't make it to the production version? I'm struggling to understand where the mismatch is, but maybe I've misunderstood what you're actually claiming to have done?

Goto P38 > EDC > then click right hand green arrow until you see BECM. Click on BECM, then settings, then Alarm. Top of first page is immobiliser that will need setting disabled. Click on right hand green arrow until you see EKA that willneed setting disabled. You can't do anything on emulator but will be able to when plugged into car. To put BECM into diagnostic mode Leave ignition OFF. Plug Nanocom in wait until it loads then goto BECM as above. After a few seconds dash message will read Diagnostic mode. Follow above then when immobiliser and EKA have been set disabled, go back one page by pressing red cross and select write settings. wait for Nanocom to do it's thing. Switch Nanocom off. Switch ignition on message should go and car will start. DO NOT start car with Nanocom on. Always switch it off before operating starter
Click to expand...
It must be done with the BECM in diagnostic mode. That is all I will say about it. Work it out yourself.
 
In my experience whenever I am ignition off and in the BeCM module on Nano the dashboard always displays "diagnostic mode". I'm not sure it's possible to be otherwise tbh - so I'm not sure what i'm meant to be "working out". You clearly can't back up your claims, so like the playground card game I'm calling "bullsh**". Probably when the immobilised car started for you, after you supposedly changed the eka/ immob settings, the passive coil kicked in and restarted the car, and you thought wey hey - it works. I've no idea cos you're a bit light on detail, no-one else has come forward saying they can do what you can, have they?

Maybe you had access to an appraisal nano years ago, but had to give it back, or you sold it/ broke it. Doesn't add up... you clearly know a lot of stuff about a P38 , infinitely more than I ever will- but at the edges you just make stuff up, and figure that if you shout it enough people will just take your word for it. No-one knows everything, that's ok... and I've seen it here, and on rr.net, the guys who've been on the site for years slowly get bored of dealing with the minions (happy amateurs, as you put it) and slowly become more obnoxious, until they find something more fulfilling to do, and the site resumes normal business.
 
It's hard to prove that something is impossible... I am always open to the fact that there's some special trick that I'm missing. But as a great person once wrote:

"So what do you do if someone is talking nonsense and misguiding others. Say nothing and let people be sent in the wrong direction. Or speak up and correct things" and "When someone, no matter who it is, posts something misguided i reserve the right to correct it. "

I spent a fairly considerable time today on my nanocom trying to replicate this, and I'm reasonably handy with it, having re-mobilised two other P38's in the last couple of months. If you are prepared to take a look at the issue (like attach a nanocom to a P38) , rather than playing forum groupie, then please help us along. I think Wammers is big enough that he doesn't need you to stick up for him
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

DollyBird
Engine disabled, keys not working, tried the guide “Re-synching the Range Rover P38 diesel engine with the Solved - BECM using a Nanocom” no luck
Replies
9
Views
1K
DollyBird
DollyBird
Flossie
P38A Am i stranded? EML on..
2 3
Replies
41
Views
2K
Rubberknees
Rubberknees
MAF Diver
Disco 2 Nanocom/RAVE manual is wrong: adjusting windows after removing key and opening a door?
Replies
4
Views
429
MAF Diver
MAF Diver
dogsbody
P38 no crank
Replies
13
Views
1K
Grrrrrr
Grrrrrr
Khemitude
P38A Becm/alarm throwing a funny
Replies
2
Views
1K
Grrrrrr
Grrrrrr
Back
Top