neilly said:
Which bits?

the number plates and the the chassis number?

Cheers
Click to expand...

Firstly I know now't about defenders other than they are noisy and get nicked a lot (and I would still like one) but I believe in general it's the chassis that goes with the V5.
Since the reg and chassis match the V5 is it possible that that the OP is worrying over nothing. Just trying to give them a glimmer of hope.
 
backinblack said:
If you paid for a history check does that not come with a certain level of insurance?

Is it not possible that someone legitimately bought a scrap TD5 and just swapped the bit's over?
Click to expand...
I would have thought that HPI checks come with some sort of insurance however they would fight tooth and nail not to pay out by then the 'ringer' is out there in the public domain, open for repossession or seizing/scrapping.

You could buy a scrap Td5 and swap over the parts, but looking at the evidence so far I would say 99% of the parts have been swapped - a lot of work, would be easier to just buy a Td5 in the first place.
 
wireman said:
I would have thought that HPI checks come with some sort of insurance however they would fight tooth and nail not to pay out by then the 'ringer' is out there in the public domain, open for repossession or seizing/scrapping.

You could buy a scrap Td5 and swap over the parts, but looking at the evidence so far I would say 99% of the parts have been swapped - a lot of work, would be easier to just buy a Td5 in the first place.
Click to expand...

The thing with the HPI check is in essence its right, id for the vehicle wont show as stolen as it would be the TD5 that is. For someone like me with limited knowledge it all checked out. The V5 says 90 Defender Turbo Diesel 2.5 ltr - check. Body type - ligth 4x4 utility - check colour - green - check VIN number - Check
 
backinblack said:
Since the reg and chassis match the V5
Click to expand...

This is my take on it.

Chassis appears to be TD5 , fuel tank position, cross member.
Body is TD5
Engine is TD5

Stamped chassis number is for a 91 vehicle.

I think if it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck and walks like a duck, chances are it is a ???

As an example, I could argue the above by saying the follwoing.

Mine has tD5 body from the bulkhead back,
but the fuel tank sits in the original place on the chassis.
Engine is 300tdi, but I can see where the original 19J engine mounts places were.

As I said before , I would suggest the OP, scrubs the chassis clean by the chassis number and looks to see if there is any welding there.

Cheers
 
neilly said:
This is my take on it.

Chassis appears to be TD5 , fuel tank position, cross member.
Body is TD5
Engine is TD5

Stamped chassis number is for a 91 vehicle.

I think if it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck and walks like a duck, chances are it is a ???

As an example, I could argue the above by saying the follwoing.

Mine has tD5 body from the bulkhead back,
but the fuel tank sits in the original place on the chassis.
Engine is 300tdi, but I can see where the original 19J engine mounts places were.

As I said before , I would suggest the OP, scrubs the chassis clean by the chassis number and looks to see if there is any welding there.

Cheers
Click to expand...
:D:D
 
neilly said:
This is my take on it.

Chassis appears to be TD5 , fuel tank position, cross member.
Body is TD5
Engine is TD5

Stamped chassis number is for a 91 vehicle.

I think if it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck and walks like a duck, chances are it is a ???

As an example, I could argue the above by saying the follwoing.

Mine has tD5 body from the bulkhead back,
but the fuel tank sits in the original place on the chassis.
Engine is 300tdi, but I can see where the original 19J engine mounts places were.

As I said before , I would suggest the OP, scrubs the chassis clean by the chassis number and looks to see if there is any welding there.

Cheers
Click to expand...

I think its increasingly looking like its a TD5, the question is what do i do for the best ? What happens in 5 years if i want to sell it? do i just say its past can't be verified. Would putting it on a private plate make a difference or make it look more dodgy ? Thanks
 
Look on the bright side, in 31 posts time you'll be able to add it to the sales and want on here :D

TBH, enjoy the thing whatever it costs as it'll eat through 3x that just to keep it on the road. I'm not planning on ever selling mine so I much not care about its provenance ;)
 
AL1975 said:
I think its increasingly looking like its a TD5, the question is what do i do for the best ? What happens in 5 years if i want to sell it? do i just say its past can't be verified. Would putting it on a private plate make a difference or make it look more dodgy ? Thanks
Click to expand...

If you were to try and sell it to anyone who knows landies , then they would question it. Anyone else probably would not notice it.

Personally , I would not touch it if I was offered it.

As I said above. I would scrub the area on the chassis, check to see if you can see welding. See what you can find.

Sorry, but that is how I see it.

Goodluck and I hope I am wrong.

Cheers
 
AL1975 said:
I think its increasingly looking like its a TD5, the question is what do i do for the best ? What happens in 5 years if i want to sell it? do i just say its past can't be verified. Would putting it on a private plate make a difference or make it look more dodgy ? Thanks
Click to expand...
Thats a very good question, private plates could help, never thought about that really. I would keep it and act dumb. Bling it up and enjoy it, whatever harm has been done is in the past as long as it stays there all is well. I'd be angry though that I'd been conned and would probably start shouting and chucking things at the bloke that sold it......bet you can't find him now though. If you can get hold of him face him off about it and gauge his reaction, then you'll know for sure.
 
This chap might be able to help
Unknown.jpeg
 
if you swap parts from one vehicle to another, isn't there a totting up to how much you can do? or am i thinking of something else?
 
I can't see what you are worrying about, paperwork all checks out ok and it has passed the MOT checks which include vehicle i.d check and there are many, many older defenders on the road that have had some parts or whole body or chassis swapped from newer defenders. Use it enjoy it keep it and stop worrying. (A defender is for life not just for Christmas.) Unless it gets nicked.
 
Rodeo Joe said:
Thats a very good question, private plates could help, never thought about that really. I would keep it and act dumb. Bling it up and enjoy it, whatever harm has been done is in the past as long as it stays there all is well. I'd be angry though that I'd been conned and would probably start shouting and chucking things at the bloke that sold it......bet you can't find him now though. If you can get hold of him face him off about it and gauge his reaction, then you'll know for sure.
Click to expand...

I do have the guys number still i think so will get in touch and say it looks like it was stolen in the past, who reckons i'll get no answer??
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Globetreka
300Tdi or Td5?
Replies
2
Views
303
tottot
tottot
R
Project 1998 300tdi that i am looking to move on.
Replies
0
Views
514
robin993
R
C
fair price for a 110 200TDi?
Replies
5
Views
617
captainmish
C
RobertJ
COC data Defender 90 Td5
Replies
0
Views
278
RobertJ
RobertJ
M
1984 90 whats it worth?
Replies
7
Views
727
Forestrax4x4
F