Despair finding a mechanic!

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.

mikerajjers

Well-Known Member
Posts
1,467
Location
Bedford UK or Trnava SK
Hi all, I'm finding it near impossible finding a decent mechanic. I've tried five in the past two or three years but each has either been dishonest, done bad jobs or simply cut corners. I have been resorting to doing all the fixes myself having had absolutely no experience a couple of years ago. I could barely change a wheel and now I can do a whole axle rebuild. I am currently faced with a daunting task of changing my gearbox and transfer box but not sure whether I will be able to manage. Is it 'easy' enough to do? What are the tell tale signs of finding a good or bad mechanic?
 
Hi all, I'm finding it near impossible finding a decent mechanic. I've tried five in the past two or three years but each has either been dishonest, done bad jobs or simply cut corners. I have been resorting to doing all the fixes myself having had absolutely no experience a couple of years ago. I could barely change a wheel and now I can do a whole axle rebuild. I am currently faced with a daunting task of changing my gearbox and transfer box but not sure whether I will be able to manage. Is it 'easy' enough to do? What are the tell tale signs of finding a good or bad mechanic?


If you can rebuild an axle, changing the gearbox and Tbox should be a doddle!
 
Like mick say's,if you can overhaul an axle you can change a gearbox/transferbox. All you need are the right tools for the job and a mate to help get them back in is helpfull. I am sure you are aware these are weighty items and to do the job safely you will need an engine crane or similar. Do not try balancing them on a trolly jack unless it is fitted with a frame to hold the box. Even so I recon from the top is best and safest.
 
I have a repurposed gearbox mount that fits into my trolley jack, from above is more tricky on a disco as theres only a small hole through the tunnel
 
Cheers for your reply guys! You have filled me with confidence that I may be able to do it myself. If you say an axle rebuild is easier then I should be able to manage it. Can the items be lifted from the top? I could probably do it at work where we have a fork lift truck. I'm sure I'll be able to find a detailed description online.
 
Cheers for your reply guys! You have filled me with confidence that I may be able to do it myself. If you say an axle rebuild is easier then I should be able to manage it. Can the items be lifted from the top? I could probably do it at work where we have a fork lift truck. I'm sure I'll be able to find a detailed description online.

You remove the floor panels, gearbox tunnel and the inspection hatch under the centre seat. This then gives you enough room to lower/lift with an engine crane. The boxes need supporting while you unbolt it, and slide it back and then you lower them to the floor. I would suggest an engine crane would probably be better than a forklift as you can still work around it and have a it more control as it is slower. But if is definitely not a technically difficult job, it is just heavy.
 
is it possible to remove the transferbox without removing the gearbox? The former is nackered for sure and needs replacing. The gearbox may still be ok but I really don´t know. I get a massive vibration thoughout the vehicle doing anything above about 40kmph.
 
is it possible to remove the transferbox without removing the gearbox?
Yes, the transfer box is at the rear so is quite easy to remove. Personally I can remove and refit the transfer box without the use of a crane and instead just lift it into position with some one inside to guide it into place as I slide it forward. It is however still heavy and not everyone will be able to do this. I am still young enough and strong enough to happily lay on my back under the vehicle with the box sat on my chest. I know this will not always be the case as I get older.

Here are a couple of guide on how to do the transfer box but it appears both have lost their pictures:
Link 1
Link 2

A basic list of small jobs you need to do is:
Remove the floor panels, gearbox tunnel and centre seat inspection hatch
Drain the transfer box
Remove both props
Remove the speedo cable
Remove the handbrake cable
Remove the hand brake drum and back plate (not sure if you need to do this have a disc conversion and the caliper does not allow it to move far enough back so needs to be removed)
Disconnect the diff lock switch wiring and breather pipe
Disconnect the gear and diff lock linkage (i undo the middle of the linkage for the gear selector at the threaded adjuster)
Support on a jack and remover the transfer box chassis mount
Remove all of the bolts holding it to the gearbox noting their position (they are not all the same)
Slide the box back and lower to the ground checking nothing is still attached
Refitting is just the reverse

Some people will remove the input gear before removing or refitting the box but I have never found this to be necessary.
 
If the gearbox is ok and not need replacing then I would rather not
Are you sure your wheels rims are not damaged or massively out of balance?
100 percent sure. The rims are less than a year old and I tried with a different set that was freshly balanced. I've gradually repaired lots of bits over the past year, which I thought may be causing these vibrations. I am 99.9 percent certain it is either the gearbox or transfer box and I have been saving up to replace them both. I havent driven it more than 10km for the past 3-4 months and I really miss it now
 
or props/UJ's.
When transfer or gearboxes fail they normally whine as the bearings give out rather than vibrate.
I have eliminated evertyhing else I could think of...here is just what I can remember changing over the past year
both props {rear changed twice)
steering rods
steering arm
rear diff (brand new ashcroft}
front left swivel/hub rebuild
complete rear axle rebuild
gearbox mounts
clutch
dual mass flywheel

I did a spell of offroading and that killed off the rear diff...so I think the transferbox got shot at the same time.
 
BTW I didnt change the clutch or flywheel myself...did the other bits though. The mechanic that changed the clutch was a let down...whole interior left covered in oil and didnt bother checking whether the drivetrain was ok.
 
BTW I didnt change the clutch or flywheel myself...did the other bits though. The mechanic that changed the clutch was a let down...whole interior left covered in oil and didnt bother checking whether the drivetrain was ok.
If there's one thing I hate, it's oily hand marks on the vehicle , usually the head lining by the front door pillar as they haul their lazy arse out of the vehicle.
As has been said, removing both boxes will be easy for you. The main problem will be balancing them on a trolley jack, awkward but doable
 
Its not hard, but its heavy and awkward, top tip is dont cut any corners whilst you are in there, ie seals/clutch, basically anyhting that if it goes wrong means box removal again.

There are decent mechs out there, aadly for you land rovers especially the old crap are specialised bits of kit and your general quick fit person might not be to clued up.
Got any hgv workshops near you?
 
Back
Top