Failed MOT..for this...

DIFFLOCK66 · Jun 2, 2014

Yep, there's a hole beneath the silver duct tape. I found the hole not long after I'd bought the Disco, as in I managed to poke it through whilst picking at some rusty paint! :doh: Anyway wire brushed it and Hammerited the edges, then duct taped over it to cut down any water ingress.

Trouble is, the hole is within 30 cm of the brake master cylinder & servo - they're important bits, don't you know!?

Hopefully get it welded up this week and then back for a (very!) short retest!

Only advisories were rear pads wearing unevenly, O/S front shock bottom bush worn (I do have another!), front exhaust has minor leak (the steel mesh is showing black soot) and slight cut on O/S/R tyre.

Emissions were 0.63 out of the permissible 3 so happy days (and she sounded great whilst being revved!)

defender11069 · Jun 2, 2014

he failed it on that...

biggeeeee · Jun 2, 2014

Blurry hell

DIFFLOCK66 · Jun 2, 2014

Aye! Excessive corrosion AKA a hole, within the prescribed area.. No wonder we don't see too many proper Minis on the road...everything is within 30cm of everything else.!

Maybe he was jealous of the top welding job on the N/S chassis rail

jbenekeorr · Jun 2, 2014

A little off topic - but what does that plug in the picture do? Mine has the plugs but nothing connected. Always been curious!

joojar · Jun 2, 2014

jbenekeorr said:
A little off topic - but what does that plug in the picture do? Mine has the plugs but nothing connected. Always been curious!

Heated windscreen

jbenekeorr · Jun 2, 2014

joojar said:
Heated windscreen

Thanks!

Vanmancan · Jun 2, 2014

If it was me I would rub off that yellow arrow . It must of drawn his attention straight to the hole !!!!!!

Naytdawg · Jun 2, 2014

you seem to have a right prick of a mechanic, find a backstreet cash only bloke next year!

dieselreek · Jun 2, 2014

a couple of years back the mot tester was going to fail my disco for a hole in inner wing, said it was too close to the suspension

Saltlick · Jun 3, 2014

dieselreek said:
a couple of years back the mot tester was going to fail my disco for a hole in inner wing, said it was too close to the suspension

....and? You seem to have stopped mid sentence!

dieselreek · Jun 3, 2014

Saltlick said:
....and? You seem to have stopped mid sentence!

told him not to be so bloody stupid the inner wing only held up the electrics and had nothing to do with suspension

Silverlandy · Jun 3, 2014

DIFFLOCK66 said:
Aye! Excessive corrosion AKA a hole, within the prescribed area.. No wonder we don't see too many proper Minis on the road...everything is within 30cm of everything else.!

Maybe he was jealous of the top welding job on the N/S chassis rail

On the bright side, at least he's thorough. Anal, but thorough

DIFFLOCK66 · Jun 3, 2014

Vanmancan said:
If it was me I would rub off that yellow arrow . It must of drawn his attention straight to the hole !!!!!!

Ah, there's always one!

(Made me laugh though! :high5: )

DIFFLOCK66 · Jun 3, 2014

Naty - no he's just thorough I guess. Mind you - it'd be interesting to find out just how much metal you could cut away from that area before it affected the structural integrity of the brake servo mount. Wouldn't there be some kind of strengthening webs on the other side of the bulkhead where the pedal bracketry bolts to? I reckon the bonnet hinge would fall off first!

200tdi ayre · Jun 3, 2014

Technically he cant fail you for that as he cant see the actual rust, and testers arnt allowed to remove anything durung a test (apart from lifting bonnet etc) so how would he know what was behind the tape.

He can tap it with the inspection tool and if it goes through he can fail and fail as a inadequate repair. Just being tough

It is a fail though if visable. But you cant complain about testers being thorough. It could sace your life one day

DIFFLOCK66 · Jun 3, 2014

200tdi ayre said:
But you cant complain about testers being thorough. It could sace your life one day

No argument there, especially if it's a common sense fail & not "you can't have orange sidelights" fail (long story, American car

)

I didn't actually see what he did - I've been told about the "not being allowed to remove stuff" aspect. I suspect he tapped it with the toffee hammer - a dead giveaway on duct tape with a hole behind it!

200tdi ayre · Jun 3, 2014

DIFFLOCK66 said:
No argument there, especially if it's a common sense fail & not "you can't have orange sidelights" fail (long story, American car )

I didn't actually see what he did - I've been told about the "not being allowed to remove stuff" aspect. I suspect he tapped it with the toffee hammer - a dead giveaway on duct tape with a hole behind it!

I may be wrong about the inadequate repair bit, he may be able to fail for it being made if duct tape alone without being able to make a hole in it, but for say rust the "tiffie hammer" has to go through.

Ill do my testers course soon and let you know

DIFFLOCK66 · Jun 3, 2014

200tdi ayre said:
Ill do my testers course soon and let you know

SWEET! Cheap, sensible MOT tests..... in Australia. Hang on while I arrange a friendly Antonov transport jet to get me and the Disco over to Oz

Good luck on the course!

200tdi ayre · Jun 3, 2014

DIFFLOCK66 said:
SWEET! Cheap, sensible MOT tests..... in Australia. Hang on while I arrange a friendly Antonov transport jet to get me and the Disco over to Oz

Good luck on the course!

Dont worry ive got a airstrip on farm. I can unload from the antanov straight into the shed and should be back to you in 5-7 working days !!

Failed MOT..for this...

Well-Known Member

AKA Mr cool...

Retired - Living the dream

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Active Member

Active Member

Active Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

3.5efi's other half

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Similar threads