need help deciding BMW X5 v Range Rover v Porsche Cayenne

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.
This just reminded me of my decision to buy an L322 all those years ago. I wanted an L322, or as it was known at the time, 'the new Range Rover'. I loved the look of it, it made my Disco( and most other 4x4s) look rudimentary, BUT, I decided to be sensible, for once, and look at other 4x4s.
I looked at the Cayenne , decided it was ugly, and, like the cars, my leg hit the steering every time I braked.
I looked at J**p , they were ok but felt cheap, and, I couldn't past the 'dad's , wife and 2.4 kids ' looks
I looked at Volvo, but it felt like a Ford. Enough said .
I looked at Toyota, and boy did I love it. It turned my head from the L322, although my heart was still in love with the Range Rover. All butch, and glossy, with leather interior. All kinds of gadgets galore. Even the promise of being able to tow the horsebox AND be able to get out of muddy fields. Wow! The Range Rover was still winning but only by a hair. Until the test drive.
What an uncomfortable place to live. Nothing was quite right. However, the clincher was the same as the Cayenne: every time I braked , my knee hit the steering wheel. Before anyone says 'you can adjust them', well duh , yeah. That was with it at highest point.
So, in summary, many may make claim to be as good as, or be similar to, but , if you are after a luxury 4x4, even if you are never going to use it for it's proper role, I have yet to meet one that outshines the Range Rover.





Especially if you are tall.;)

Odd how many of us are over 6'. I know not all are and know of at least one wife with wooden blocks on the pedals but for the rest of is the extra space makes all the difference. I start the new diet next week .. or failing that the week after.
 
so looking at the E53 BMW X5, the L322 Range Rover and the MK1 Porsche Cayenne

reliability is important to me more then performance
You will get many addictive qualities from a Range Rover, we all made the decision to own one, the 4.2 SC is a peach in your price bracket, I would love the 5.0 SC, but keep in mind the Japanese have no words to describe a Recovery Vehicle . :)
 
I often wonder how so many live with the unreliability of range rovers, I also wonder how you cope with the cost of fuel. Does the first cancel out the second, after all, if it's broken down, it's not using any fuel. Is that how you all afford to own them?

Col
The P38 is cheap to run but never without it's niggles, I now have 2 on the road to try and ensure one is always available to use:rolleyes:. As for fuel, 24 to 30 mpg is no worse than my 1600cc sports car:D
 
Now I would never think of calling a young lady "mate" , maybe I`m old fashion`d or is it just old I cant remember must be an age thing again !

I think I find it acceptable because of it's prevalence within the Army. Also some of the female types objected to me calling them 'sweetie'. Oddly enough the guys were quite happy with it :D



Addit: I also find it much more acceptable than 'gents' ;)
 
Odd how many of us are over 6'. I know not all are and know of at least one wife with wooden blocks on the pedals but for the rest of is the extra space makes all the difference. I start the new diet next week .. or failing that the week after.

Maybe it's a chicken or the egg thing. Did we end up buying because we are tall? Or would we have bought regardless of height?
I know my decision would have been more difficult, had the Toyota not been such an awkward space.
 
It's not so much your height that is a problem, it's the ratio between your torso length and leg length. I'm 6ft 3 but I have a long body and average length legs so legroom isn't a problem in most cars but headroom is and I have problems reading the speedo. It's a bit of a problem in my series cos my eye level is level with the top of the with the top of the windscreen so seeing traffic lights at junctions means I have to lean over the steering wheel.

Col
 
I wasn't fussed about the leg room, it was the sunroof that had me sold..:)

cone.jpg
 
Maybe it's a chicken or the egg thing. Did we end up buying because we are tall? Or would we have bought regardless of height?
I know my decision would have been more difficult, had the Toyota not been such an awkward space.
Don't bring me in to this, you already had one before I came along :p
 
You will get many addictive qualities from a Range Rover, we all made the decision to own one, the 4.2 SC is a peach in your price bracket, I would love the 5.0 SC, but keep in mind the Japanese have no words to describe a Recovery Vehicle . :)

i do love the l322 but just dont want the headache of issues and yea i know that can happen with any used car, but you get my drift?
 
A Range Rover is not a car, it's a hobby and if you cannot DIY it becomes a very expensive hobby:rolleyes: A spare car is always a good investment to go with your Range Rover:cool:
Couldn’t agree more, I had a company car Till 2018 as well as my wife’s. We also keep my daughters car at our house in case Mrs Tricky is at the shops. For me it’s the smile every time you drive the Range. The fixing stuff is a bonus.
Tricky.
 
Back
Top