MOT and EGR valve.

landy-lee

Well-Known Member

Posts

706

Location

derby

• Jan 3, 2019

• #1

Hi guys.

I am about to book my 300tdi defender in for a MOT soon but i have just found out that as part of the mot changes any tampering with the EGR system is a fail?

I have removed my EGR.

Has anyone had any experiences with this and your MOT?

 

Wimblowdriver

Well-Known Member

Full Member

Posts

6,593

Location

uk

• Jan 3, 2019

• #2

Item a) at the bottom of the page.

 

Attachments

• mot-inspection-manual-for-classes-3-4-5-and-7-from-20-may-2018-draft (dragged).pdf

  130.6 KB · Views: 133

landy-lee

Well-Known Member

Posts

706

Location

derby

• Jan 3, 2019

• #3

Cheers wimblowdriver

But does that only apply to cars fitted with a DPF because the smoke test only applies to cars fitted with DPF filters.

 

Wimblowdriver

Well-Known Member

Full Member

Posts

6,593

Location

uk

• Jan 3, 2019

• #4

I'm sure a proper MOT tester will be along soon to answer that, but the bit about inspection of the components includes DPF, Cat and Selective Catalytic Reduction Valves. So, is an EGR a selective reduction valve? I would have thought so.

 

TorsionBhudda

Well-Known Member

Posts

1,342

Location

Falkirk

• Jan 3, 2019

• #5

The egr is removed from my daughters TD5 and it sailed through MOT couple months ago

 

Interceptorxj

Well-Known Member

Posts

1,718

Location

Bolton, Greater Manchester.

• Jan 3, 2019

• #6

Yes it should now be a major fail , but I haven't read anywhere of any failing with EGR deletes etc. (there have been several threads on this in the last 12 months) Mine sailed through no problem.

 

bluedog333

Well-Known Member

Posts

5,442

Location

Henley on Thames, Oxfordshire

• Jan 3, 2019

• #7

Depends on which garage you go to, some are only concerned with DPFs and Cats, as these are a lot easier to access.

 

Al2O3

Well-Known Member

Full Member

Posts

11,023

Location

North of the Wall

• Jan 3, 2019

• #8

Yeah, it should be a fail. Mine passed with it missing too. Worth a try as many testers are either turning a blind eye or don't know that Defenders of a certain age had thwm.

 

Scooby22

Well-Known Member

Posts

1,247

Location

County Durham

• Jan 3, 2019

• #9

I refitted my EGR and CAT before getting my 2004 TD5 tested, my MOT tester is a indi landrover repair specialist and he told me he failed a disco a few weeks before I took mine in because both EGR and CAT had been removed, I have read other garages have passed them with them being removed, maybe some have engine covers off so it's easy to spot and others that have passed have engine covers on so hiding the EGR. Or some just don't know which had them originally.
Ironically he rang me to say mine would not pass as one of my electric headlight beam height adjusters was not operating, which if fitted now have to work under the new rules, even though headlight alignment was fine.
He did not register a fail but sorted it and gave me a pass, it had been like that for 12 years I've owned it, I forgot about it.

 

N

NorthernEscapes

Member

Posts

57

Location

Manchester

• Jan 4, 2019

• #10

They are very unlikely to manually check for an EGR valve - that check isn't part of the MOT. Try not to point out it's missing. Many MOT people are not proper mechanics and wouldn't know one anyway. Ive had an EGR delete and my mate who owns a garage assures me they will never notice on emissions. Ive a Renault van with it blocked off and removed and they never notice either.

You could always make a replica - take a toilet roll and a length of pipe and make something that looks like a hippie bong and spray it black. Rub it in the dirt so it looks rusty and knackered. Then it will look the part. Maybe put a white round sticker on it and write "Checked" with a big tick next to it.

You'll be fine

Jon