Front propshaft phase offset

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.
Grrrrrr said:
Are the Britpart ones designed to go on the Disco 2 too? So no "key spline"? Can you pop them apart and twist to correct angle and reconnect? Cannot remember how many splines there are but should be easy enough to calculate angle from number of splines twisted.
Click to expand...

No idea. I haven't popped it apart either. I'm sending it back so don't want to damage it. They're not right out of the box though.
 
Last edited:
The picture of shown on your link Wammers is different to the propshafts I have seen on P38s.

The ridged rubber boot is different so I don't think we can trust the image Rimmer Bros are using. More likely they're just using a generic image of a propshaft for their shop.

Many people all over the world have reported on Land Rover forums that the front prop shaft is phased slightly.

I have three genuine ones here that are all phased.

The picture of the front propshaft in RAVE shows the UJs at either end to be out of alighnment.

I think you're wrong. The evidence that they are phased is pretty compelling.

Constantly stating "Front props on the P38 are NOT phased" in light of this much evidence to the contrary is not going to help people looking for help with this in the future. Or are you arguing semantics?
 
Last edited:
MrGorsky said:
The picture of shown on your link Wammers is different to the propshafts I have seen on P38s.

The ridged rubber boot is different so I don't think we can trust the image Rimmer Bros are using. More likely they're just using a generic image of a propshaft for their shop.

Many people all over the world have reported on Land Rover forums that the front prop shaft is phased slightly.

I have three genuine ones here that are all phased.

The picture of the front propshaft in RAVE shows the UJs at either end to be out of alighnment.

I think you're wrong. The evidence that they are phased is pretty compelling.

Constantly stating "Front props on the P38 are NOT phased" in light of this much evidence to the contrary is not going to help people looking for help with this in the future. Or are you arguing semantics?
Click to expand...

FTC4140 is the front prop from the petrols and manual diesel. TVB000130 is the front prop for the diesel automatic. Neither are phased. Only phased front props on Range rovers are fitted to classics. Range Rover 2 does not have phased props. But carry on, no skin off my nose.
 
I just want to use the correct part for the job.

Anyone else reading this please don't take Wammers word for this.

There are plenty of P38s out there that left the factory with front propshafts phased. I have 3 genuine P38 propshafts and they are all phased slightly. Photo's are above.

There's plenty of people on other forums have noticed the phasing, looked in to it, and found it to be correct.

Before you fit or refit one in phase please at least read this thread and these before making your decision about it. Genuine LR propshafts only go together one way, so you can't adjust the phase anyway.

Front Driveshaft "phase"

Front proshaft alignment

Front propshaft phase offset

Front drive shaft alignment. - Australian Land Rover Owners
 
Last edited:
MrGorsky said:
I just want to use the correct part for the job.

Anyone else reading this please don't take Wammers word for this.

There are plenty of P38s out there that left the factory with front propshafts phased. I have 3 genuine P38 propshafts and they are all phased slightly. Photo's are above.

There's plenty of people on other forums have noticed the phasing, looked in to it, and found it to be correct.

Before you fit or refit one in phase please at least read this thread and these before making your decision about it. Genuine LR propshafts only go together one way, so you can't adjust the phase anyway.

Front Driveshaft "phase"

Front proshaft alignment

Front propshaft phase offset

Front drive shaft alignment. - Australian Land Rover Owners
Click to expand...

They have to empty the stock bins somehow. Problem is Land rover supplied genuine P38 front prop shafts are NOT phased. What part of that do you not understand? Classic front prop. http://www.rimmerbros.co.uk/Item--i-FTC122
 
Last edited:
Or maybe some props are for more than one model and the "generic" need phasing as required for that model?

Let's see how many are phased and how many aren't. Maybe there's a changeover year?We've lots of cars on here so we should be able to unpick what has been randomly thrown on in Solihull. :)

Mine's the manual diesel and I think the props are genuine. I'll get under there this evening and take a photo.
 
Grrrrrr said:
Or maybe some props are for more than one model and the "generic" need phasing as required for that model?

Let's see how many are phased and how many aren't. Maybe there's a changeover year?We've lots of cars on here so we should be able to unpick what has been randomly thrown on in Solihull. :)

Mine's the manual diesel and I think the props are genuine. I'll get under there this evening and take a photo.
Click to expand...

There are two front prop shafts listed for P38 Range rovers according to Land rover Microcat. Both the numbers i have already posted. Neither of them is phased. Land rover may have used old stock from the Classic, also owners may have fitted the wrong shaft. It doesn't really matter either way. But if you are looking to buy a new front prop for your car according to VIN, do not expect it to be phased even if the one you remove is.
 
I understand your statement Wamners. It's just that constantly bleating "P38 front prop shafts are not phased" without any evidence to back up your statement isn't much good to anyone.

Especially when there is loads of evidence around to suggest otherwise. Am I supposed to accept it just because you repeat yourself a lot and start saying "do what you want, it's no skin off my nose"

Mentioning that you think LR may have fitted old classic prop shafts to some P38s at the factory would have helped enormously.

They clearly fitted them to more than just a few if people on several continents have found the same as me.

I'm still suspicious that the illustrations in RAVE show a phased shaft. Can you provide me with any evidence that they shouldn't be phased?

In fact please don't.
 
MrGorsky said:
I understand your statement Wamners. It's just that constantly bleating "P38 front prop shafts are not phased" without any evidence to back up your statement isn't much good to anyone.

Especially when there is loads of evidence around to suggest otherwise. Am I supposed to accept it just because you repeat yourself a lot and start saying "do what you want, it's no skin off my nose"

Mentioning that you think LR may have fitted old classic prop shafts to some P38s at the factory would have helped enormously.

They clearly fitted them to more than just a few if people on several continents have found the same as me.

I'm still suspicious that the illustrations in RAVE show a phased shaft. Can you provide me with any evidence that they shouldn't be phased?

In fact please don't.
Click to expand...

How much evidence do you need? Order a new prop, it can only be one of two part numbers according to what model you own, and see what you get. Look at the bloody parts list.
 
Last edited:
just to add to my post of ages ago regarding this - I have changed dozens of uj's on p38s and have never found a front one "in phase" yet ... all have been offset out of phase, all have had a key spline and all have been nice and smooth after wards.
 
wantaquad said:
just to add to my post of ages ago regarding this - I have changed dozens of uj's on p38s and have never found a front one "in phase" yet ... all have been offset out of phase, all have had a key spline and all have been nice and smooth after wards.
Click to expand...

They were fitted with the wrong front prop shaft then. Simples. As i have repeated ad nauseum. There are only two front prop shafts listed for the P38 and neither of them is phased. If you order a new front prop from the VIN number of your car you WILL NOT get a phased front prop. What part of that do you not understand? If you do get a phased front prop it WILL NOT be the correct part. It will fit and function but is not the correct part. Of course Land rover and their parts list, and all the manufactures who make pattern parts to the part numbers maybe totally wrong, but i doubt it.
 
wammers said:
There are two front prop shafts listed for P38 Range rovers according to Land rover Microcat. Both the numbers i have already posted. Neither of them is phased. Land rover may have used old stock from the Classic, also owners may have fitted the wrong shaft. It doesn't really matter either way. But if you are looking to buy a new front prop for your car according to VIN, do not expect it to be phased even if the one you remove is.
Click to expand...

I've been Wammered!

http://m.brujula.net/juegos/gopher/index-en.html

:D:D:D
 
Even the picture in Microcat shows the two ends don't line up but are slightly off!!

attachment.php


This is a wind up, and I've fallen for it!

Nice one Wammers, you got me.
 

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2015-04-28 at 16.56.00.png
    Screen Shot 2015-04-28 at 16.56.00.png
    63.6 KB · Views: 553
Last edited:
wammers said:
What part of the first two looks phased.
Click to expand...


No part of the first two look phased.

They look like they're after market ones not genuine ones fitted by Land Rover at the factory. They're also just photos on a shops website, not official documentation from the manufacturer.

Looking at the diagrams in RAVE, in Microcat, looking at actual parts taken off actual P38s and comparing them to the aftermarket parts you're showing us here, and on top of that countless other people's experiences I'd say they're wrong. As are you.

Can we just leave it now? If you can't accept you're mistaken after all this I think you're just never ever ever going to accept it.

Are you religious?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

N
Propshaft balance after VCU change?
Replies
2
Views
478
niko-h
N
M
Propshaft repair
Replies
8
Views
1K
martin41076
M
JoeCoutz
Defender TD5 90 - Play in front Prop Shaft - DON'T WANT TO DRIVE!
Replies
6
Views
1K
lynall
L
H
MOT Failed
Replies
3
Views
1K
Datatek
Datatek
D
Freelander 2 wobble/judder
Replies
19
Views
2K
Danger Steve
D
Back
Top