Does anyone use this sort of additive?

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.
I have heard it is useful for an mot failure that just misses out on the emissions target, but I think its only petrol engines?
 
I've used all kind of additives mostly made by Liqui moly some with noticeable effect others with less and i doubt that these new formulas would cause any damage... eventually you'll realise that the advertising is exagerated and the effect is not as expected that's all.
 
Here’s a review of the product

https://blog.motoringassist.com/car-maintenance/cataclean-work/

CONCLUSION

We were disappointed that Cataclean failed to show any soot emissions reduction in our DPF and recorded an increase. It is possible that our results could be explained by Cataclean cleaning soot from the oxidising catalytic converter, which then passed down the exhaust and into the DPF. However, if that were the case (and I have no proof about it being so), then the statement about Cataclean reducing soot levels and enhancing DPF reliability remains questionable, when the results of our tests are considered.

We presented our findings to Cataclean, the resulting full statement from which is at the bottom of this blog. All I can add further is that I would need concrete evidence that Cataclean reduces soot in a DPF, beyond anecdotal claims and analysis that is funded by the maker, before I invest my own money in a bottle. It was decided not to extend the tests further, before refuelling, because the chosen methodology ran the tests for longer, at a low fuel level, than the consumer instructions the bottle indicated, when both time and mileage are considered.
 
gstuart said:
Here’s a review of the product

https://blog.motoringassist.com/car-maintenance/cataclean-work/

CONCLUSION

We were disappointed that Cataclean failed to show any soot emissions reduction in our DPF and recorded an increase. It is possible that our results could be explained by Cataclean cleaning soot from the oxidising catalytic converter, which then passed down the exhaust and into the DPF. However, if that were the case (and I have no proof about it being so), then the statement about Cataclean reducing soot levels and enhancing DPF reliability remains questionable, when the results of our tests are considered.

We presented our findings to Cataclean, the resulting full statement from which is at the bottom of this blog. All I can add further is that I would need concrete evidence that Cataclean reduces soot in a DPF, beyond anecdotal claims and analysis that is funded by the maker, before I invest my own money in a bottle. It was decided not to extend the tests further, before refuelling, because the chosen methodology ran the tests for longer, at a low fuel level, than the consumer instructions the bottle indicated, when both time and mileage are considered.
Click to expand...
I will give it a miss then. I have used redEx before to get it through the emissions on the MOT.
 
I'm sure that you'll find bad reviews for redex too if you search... it's a jungle out there with these products and you can't 100% rely on any review on the web, some of them are sponsored by the sellers others by the competitors, the only 100% reliable review is what you personnaly think after you tried it on your own vehicle :cool:
 
Last edited:
brianconwy said:
I have seen this advertised - https://www.cataclean.com/shop/cataclean-diesel/2

Obviously in the advert an old grimy engine suddenly becomes shinier than new. I presume its a bit like Redex. Has anyone trialled additives and what were the results? A bit worried that to have much effect they must be powerful enough to damage injector seals etc.
Click to expand...
I used it. My disco failed on emissions, the limit was 3 (of whatever they measure) and mine was 7.8, so an epic fail by any standard. A bottle of cataclean and about 20 miles of thrashing, it measured 0.14.... !!
 
I have not used any...YET.
But I was tempted when in Aldi on Tuesday as they had REDEX (for petrol & Diseasel) on sale.
Going to chuck a bottle-full in when I go to fill up next.
 
JUKE179r said:
Seafoam > Cataclean... just sayin...:D
Click to expand...


Hiya

Thought u may be interested

https://blog.motoringassist.com/car-maintenance/cataclean-work/

CONCLUSION

We were disappointed that Cataclean failed to show any soot emissions reduction in our DPF and recorded an increase. It is possible that our results could be explained by Cataclean cleaning soot from the oxidising catalytic converter, which then passed down the exhaust and into the DPF. However, if that were the case (and I have no proof about it being so), then the statement about Cataclean reducing soot levels and enhancing DPF reliability remains questionable, when the results of our tests are considered.
 
Bobdog said:
I used it. My disco failed on emissions, the limit was 3 (of whatever they measure) and mine was 7.8, so an epic fail by any standard. A bottle of cataclean and about 20 miles of thrashing, it measured 0.14.... !!
Click to expand...


Hoyl turds batman 7.8, thats got to be some sort of record?
 
my last emissions test was max limit , 1.50 ——- final reading with both egrs blanked 0.52
 
I use this on my diesel and worked very nicely.
upload_2019-8-9_15-2-33.png
 
Bobdog said:
I used it. My disco failed on emissions, the limit was 3 (of whatever they measure) and mine was 7.8, so an epic fail by any standard. A bottle of cataclean and about 20 miles of thrashing, it measured 0.14.... !!
Click to expand...
Maybe the 20 miles of thrashing did the job? Italian tune up?

Just checked my last emissions test was 0.24. Bog standard state of tune.
 
Bobdog said:
I wouldn't know but that's what it was. Surely it can't be that unusual?
Click to expand...


Yes thats mega high, I would bet even the tester was surprised?
My old ****ty def 90 200tdi with twiddled pump was under 2 no worries and the D3 was 1.09.

Any diesel likes to be worked and every now and then wring its bloody neck.
 
I use a 50ml dose of Millers Oil for diesel, on every tank. Brilliant, and gives a boost which is cheaper that paying for Shell Premium fuel. I thought it was a placebo effect, but chucked a dose in my lads 120D BMW, and he noticed straight away...
 
The only additive I use in my Td5 is two stroke oil. Have used this for years.
138 k miles, not a bit of smoke,even when accelerating hard. Instant start.
Usually top up from half tank and add about 150ml of 2so.
If interested just google "2so in diesel " will take hours to read all.
I recommend trying it out. I buy my 2so in Morrisons at £2 for a bottle.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

hd3
Why Injectors Fail and ..
Replies
5
Views
4K
hd3
hd3
mutsnutz
found this on a site today
Replies
1
Views
1K
disco924
disco924
BOOMER
Time For A National Greenlaning Initiative?
2
Replies
35
Views
5K
muddydisco4
M
omara04
Sorry Tale of Woe... TD5 (many problems)
Replies
12
Views
4K
omara04
omara04
The Mad Hat Man
Rust Removal Using Electrolysis
Replies
15
Views
38K
Paul D
Paul D
Back
Top