BP ULTIMA DIESEL LESS MPG !!

I have a Landrover Freelander TD4 less then a year old. I have noticed that
my local BP service stn is selling Diesel Ultima which cost about 3 pence
per litre more than the regular diesel. I asked the benefits and was told
that it provides less pollution and gives much better performance. I decided
to test it in my vehicle.

Findings:-

No noticeable increase in performance, in fact I believe performance was
reduced.
About 12% less MPG.

This means that given the increase in cost and the reduced fuel economy my
fuel bill will increase by about 15% or 55 pence per gallon. It seems to me
that BP will be making a lot of money out of the motorist who uses this
fuel. Needless to say I have reverted to the normal diesel for me to use
ultima it would have to be priced at least 10 pence less than the ordinary
diesel.

Anyone else using this fuel found the same.

Regards

AB

On Fri, 23 Jan 2004 19:19:40 -0000, "Alan Buttivant"
<[email protected]> wrote:

>I have a Landrover Freelander TD4 less then a year old. I have noticed that
>my local BP service stn is selling Diesel Ultima which cost about 3 pence
>per litre more than the regular diesel. I asked the benefits and was told
>that it provides less pollution and gives much better performance. I decided
>to test it in my vehicle.

I too have a Freelander diesel, pre-TD4 model.

Diesels are by their very nature a filthy means of arranging
transport, and in my view any internal combustion engine is. Whilst
I'm okay on the idea of ensuring that the pollution my car produces is
minimised in line with government requirements I would treat any
claims of some magic snake oil making it cleaner with a great deal of
scepticism. If it was that good then government would legislate that
it must be used.

My fuel performance is about 30mpg - and my right foot isn't exactly
gentle with the accelerator most of the time. I would treat any claim
for improving the capability of the engines mpg with the same amount
of scepticism.

Snake oil salesmen are still earning a living.

PoP

Sending email to my published email address isn't
guaranteed to reach me.

"PoP" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> On Fri, 23 Jan 2004 19:19:40 -0000, "Alan Buttivant"
> <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> >I have a Landrover Freelander TD4 less then a year old. I have noticed
that
> >my local BP service stn is selling Diesel Ultima which cost about 3 pence
> >per litre more than the regular diesel. I asked the benefits and was told
> >that it provides less pollution and gives much better performance. I
decided
> >to test it in my vehicle.
>
> I too have a Freelander diesel, pre-TD4 model.
>
> Diesels are by their very nature a filthy means of arranging
> transport, and in my view any internal combustion engine is. Whilst
> I'm okay on the idea of ensuring that the pollution my car produces is
> minimised in line with government requirements I would treat any
> claims of some magic snake oil making it cleaner with a great deal of
> scepticism. If it was that good then government would legislate that
> it must be used.
>
> My fuel performance is about 30mpg - and my right foot isn't exactly
> gentle with the accelerator most of the time. I would treat any claim
> for improving the capability of the engines mpg with the same amount
> of scepticism.
>
> Snake oil salesmen are still earning a living.
>
> PoP
>
> Sending email to my published email address isn't
> guaranteed to reach me.

One effective way of improving a diesel is dual fuel.. injecting LPG into
the air intake which when ignited by the diesel sparking off in the
cylinder, casues more even burning and less unburnt diesel out the pipe.

power increase can be anything up to 30%

rhys

PoP wrote:
> I too have a Freelander diesel, pre-TD4 model.
>
> My fuel performance is about 30mpg - and my right foot isn't exactly
> gentle with the accelerator most of the time. I would treat any claim
> for improving the capability of the engines mpg with the same amount
> of scepticism.

30 mpg, I can get that from a 200 tdi disco....
Texaco seems most efficient, but some supermarket stuff is very poor.

Niel.