If the keys are lost on a car in a multi storey the AA will either send out a locksmith or an independent garage.
you sound like one of the better AA patrols. For that I can't knock you. But.......
I am a recue technician working for an Independent garage that you guys hate so much.
I deliberately drive an old truck because it is far more versatile than 'ANYTHING' the AA has. I can wade in flood water up to my windscreen height. I can recover up to 3.5 tons. Driving a flatbed I can recover any 4x4 myself if required without calling an additional vehicle. I can winch to a range of 300m with what I carry onboard and can extend that to 500m if I pop back to my landy to get the additional equipment. I carry a full toolkit, Diagnostic computer, laptop, extensive lockout kit, waders, slippery jims, puncture repair kit, locking wheel nut removers, I carry many used spare parts that I do not charge customers for. (crank sensors, cam sensors, coil packs, clutch/accelorator cables, leads points, distributor caps, remote receivers etc etc)
I work for AA, RAC, Greenflag, Brittania, Mondial, Rescue service, Autohome, AXA, Equity, GEM, etc etc.
It doesn't matter which club I co out on behalf of. I treat ALL members the same. I will always tell any member the best/cheapest way of dealing with their particular problem. I am not in the habit of ripping people off and hate peole that are. I will do everything I can to get a car going again as quickly and cheaply as possible.
I have mates in all the breakdown clubs and if there is something I don't know I will ring them to get any extra information I need. If there is something they don't know they will ring me.
I think to say the AA is best is wrong. I would NEVER go with the AA purely because I don't want my loved ones sat on the side of the road with no cover after an accident. Until the day the AA change that policy I will NOT recomment them to ANYONE.
Like I say this is not an attack on you cos you sound like one of the better patrols out there. Yes there are jobsworths that work for greenflag, but there are jobsworths that work in every breakdown club. I just pride myself on not being one of them.