200 vs 300TDi comments and guidance please

miriam

New Member

Posts

16

Location

Beautiful Orkney, although if the wind doesn't die

• Oct 28, 2005

• #1

Hi
Having spent days trying to source a 200TDi defender engine to go into my 110 Csw, I found an ex MOD 90 today with a 300TDi engine in it and thinking about getting that and flogging my 110 without an engine .

However, was just about to offer when I was told horror stories about oil problems with the 300Tdi engine. I've done a bit of net research but can't find anything conclusive.

Can anyone give me some advice on pro's and con's on the 300TDi and whether I should avoid it or if this is a viable engine.
Having had one engine (2.5TD) go pop in the last two months I really don't want to go through all that again .

thanks

 

D

drc

New Member

Posts

4

• Oct 28, 2005

• #2

If you are anywhere near Stafford, Jenkinsons Scrap yard has a 200Tdi in stock - tried buying just the alternator this morning but they won't break it so its complete.

 

miriam

New Member

Posts

16

Location

Beautiful Orkney, although if the wind doesn't die

• Oct 28, 2005

• #3

Thanks for the tip but Orkney is a long way from anywhere

how much was it though out of interest.?? may still be worth it .

thanks

 

D

drc

New Member

Posts

4

• Oct 28, 2005

• #4

Dunno - only wanted the Alternator - engine is OK. Orkney and you own a landy? You need to live less than 10 miles from Craddocks - I'm a regular!

 

miriam

New Member

Posts

16

Location

Beautiful Orkney, although if the wind doesn't die

• Oct 28, 2005

• #5

drc said:

Dunno - only wanted the Alternator - engine is OK. Orkney and you own a landy? You need to live less than 10 miles from Craddocks - I'm a regular!

Click to expand...

Probably a good thing I'm not or I'd spend even more than I do now. Would like some more scrap yards and breakers to go at though

 

miriam

New Member

Posts

16

Location

Beautiful Orkney, although if the wind doesn't die

• Oct 29, 2005

• #6

HI , if you're after a 300TDi alternator then craddocks have one on ebay. just incase it passed you by .. 10-day listing, Ends 30-Oct-05 11:00:53 GMT. Item number: 4584036450.

would still value anyone telling me any 300TDI horror stories... ( if there are any?)

thanks

 

Fired-up

New Member

Posts

99

Location

Garden of England

• Oct 29, 2005

• #7

Best Diesel engine to ever come out of solihull!

Proberly the best engine actually, I am a V8 fan too though.

Easily tuneable, powerful (for a landrover), simple to fix and maintain and of course reliable.

Keep it serviced regulary and i'll doubt you have many, if any probs.

My opinions of course

Jim

 

miriam

New Member

Posts

16

Location

Beautiful Orkney, although if the wind doesn't die

• Nov 3, 2005

• #8

Fired-up said:

Best Diesel engine to ever come out of solihull!

Proberly the best engine actually, I am a V8 fan too though.

Easily tuneable, powerful (for a landrover), simple to fix and maintain and of course reliable.

Keep it serviced regulary and i'll doubt you have many, if any probs.

My opinions of course

Jim

Click to expand...

Thanks for this. I have bought an ex MOD 90 with a 300TDi transplant.. She is FANTASTIC and has so many hidden old MOD features I just didn;t appreciate were there when I purchased her.
SO.. anyone want to buy a 110CSW that needs an engine transplant
Miriam

 

B

barryhull12

New Member

Posts

1

• Nov 4, 2005

• #9

the 300 tdi engine in my disco has covered 156,000 miles still gives a top end of 95+ and returns 30mpg lovely lump to have barry

 

H

Hippy

Member

Posts

25

Location

Hull / East Yorkshire

• Nov 10, 2005

• #10

same power and torque, but injection preassure is marginaly higher in the 300 and makes it run slightly smoother via a bit of witch craft. ...both very good motors !

buy the 300 if you can...if you can only settle for a 200 ...its hardly any different so dont worrie

Hippy

 

miriam

New Member

Posts

16

Location

Beautiful Orkney, although if the wind doesn't die

• Nov 13, 2005

• #11

you're right about the 300 . Yes it was the right choice.
she's a beut.. Will go and post a photo of her elsewhere on the site.

thanks all for yout input.. much appreciated.
sold my 110 too this weekend so I'm just a one landy family again .

 

H

Hippy

Member

Posts

25

Location

Hull / East Yorkshire

• Nov 13, 2005

• #12

Good stuff, glad it all worked out well and you got what you want.



Hippy

 

W

Wayne

Member

Posts

30

• Nov 14, 2005

• #13

Had my 300TDi for about 6 months - my first landy so I'm probably not qualified to comment ito pro's and con's. Having said that, I wouldn't change it for anything - they don't leak oil, they are just marking territory. Another plus is that on purchasing a Defender (here in SA), all other Defender owners become your friends, it's a great feeling!!