Had a 200di in mine for the best part of 10 years...cant say its noisy...quiter that the old 2.25 it replaces...maybe me having 3.5 diffs helps with the noise.
A very unstressed economical engine...stll going strong.
The Tdi is more noisy. Lots of info on the web. If you took an old neglected 2.25 out and replaced it with a 200 and new mounts and such. Then yes it may appear quieter. But it is only appearance.
Just like the 2.5 TD 19J is also smoother and quieter than a Tdi.
The real benefit of the Tdi’s are the turbo bit. And the ability to take the boost. In n/a form you get neither of these benefits.
I’m not saying it isn’t a good motor still. Just a lot of effort for little gain.
We know a 2.5 NAD makes 67hp. And a 2.5 TD 89hp. That’s a 22hp gain. A Tdi is intercooled and runs more boost and iirc the static CR is lower. So it is reasonable to assume a Tdi makes in excess of 22hp more than it would n/a.
107hp for a Defender 200Tdi minus say 30hp (but maybe more) is 77hp. A stock 2.25 petrol in good order makes 72hp and will be a heck of a lot more refined and quieter than the diesel.
I admit finding a NaD these days might be more difficult. And maybe you are making almost 10hp more. But it seems a lot of work and money to get what actually is a less refined engine and only 10hp on top.
Mpg wise. A turbo variant is unlikely to be any worse on fuel really. Hence why all modern cars striving for good mpg are turbocharged. And mpg only really matters if you are doing big mileage in a Series. Which most people probably aren’t.
I suspect for refinement a 2.5 petrol from a 90 would probably be quite a nice setup.
I’m not knocking your vehicle. But you may want to consider fitting a turbo. It will make a bigger difference than it did going from a 2.25 to what you have now.
As for tall gearing. 3.54 diffs and stock Series gearing otherwise does indeed make it taller. But tbh without a turbo probably a little too tall for some uses and at certain times. I bet you struggle to make much use of 4th gear under 40mph. And then only on the flat or downhill sections.