Surprisingly, they would. Old habits die hard. Electric would always have been better, full power cooling at low revs, less water/mud splatter in the engine bay when off road, quicker warm up, quieter and very slight improvement in economy not to mention better acess to the front of the engine etc
I have a 200tdi. I took mine off over the summer here in France and drove down to the south of France without a fan. The engine only went towards the red when I was going up a long hill in 35 degrees. I fitted a Kenlow electric fan as the engine never warmed up in the winter even though I fitted thermostat etc. You can get cheaper electric fans for a quarter of the price of a Kenlow. I have now run mine here in France and I have only heard the fan come on once in two years.
I have a 200tdi. I took mine off over the summer here in France and drove down to the south of France without a fan. The engine only went towards the red when I was going up a long hill in 35 degrees. I fitted a Kenlow electric fan as the engine never warmed up in the winter even though I fitted thermostat etc. You can get cheaper electric fans for a quarter of the price of a Kenlow. I have now run mine here in France and I have only heard the fan come on once in two years.
We had a couple of strangely hot days this year it was 37-38c driving in the city stop start traffic (although not a hill in site) I wouldn't of taken any car without a fan that day
I think the diff here is that the peeps that don't have a fan know it doesn't cause a problem, or if so, very rarely.
The peeps that have a fan, don't want to take the risk.
Here at LandyZone we have plenty of very knowledgable members so if you have any questions about your Land Rover or just want to connect with other Landy owners, you're in the right place.