transmission question

N

Nobody

Guest

• Jan 31, 2006

• #1

I would like some opinions about my idea of increasing the life of my
automatic tranny. When I run up on slow changing lights or stoped traffic
like at train tracks I like to shift my tranny into N. Do you feel this
reduces wear or actually increases wear or does not make any difference.

Im thinking it helps because when you sit with your foot on the brake the
wheels still want to pull a little even though the engine is at a slow idle.
(friction = wear)

 

B

.boB

Guest

• Jan 31, 2006

• #2

Nobody wrote:
> I would like some opinions about my idea of increasing the life of my
> automatic tranny. When I run up on slow changing lights or stoped traffic
> like at train tracks I like to shift my tranny into N. Do you feel this
> reduces wear or actually increases wear or does not make any difference.
>
> Im thinking it helps because when you sit with your foot on the brake the
> wheels still want to pull a little even though the engine is at a slow idle.
> (friction = wear)
>
>
>
>
The shifting back and forth will increase wear on those parts in motion. Just
put it in D and leave it there.

--
..boB
On Order: 2006 FXDI, Red.
1997 HD FXDWG - Turbocharged Stolen 11/26/05 in Denver
1HD1GEL10VY3200010 CO License J5822Z
2001 Dodge Dakota QC 5.9/4x4/3.92
1966 Mustang Coupe - Daily Driver
1965 FFR Cobra - 427W EFI, Damn Fast.

 

T

TheSnoMan

Guest

• Jan 31, 2006

• #3

..boB wrote:
> Nobody wrote:
>> I would like some opinions about my idea of increasing the life of my
>> automatic tranny. When I run up on slow changing lights or stoped
>> traffic like at train tracks I like to shift my tranny into N. Do you
>> feel this reduces wear or actually increases wear or does not make any
>> difference.
>>
>> Im thinking it helps because when you sit with your foot on the brake
>> the wheels still want to pull a little even though the engine is at a
>> slow idle. (friction = wear)
>>
>>
>>
>>
> The shifting back and forth will increase wear on those parts in
> motion. Just put it in D and leave it there.
>


If it "wears" anything, it will be the linkage on the shifter.

--

-----------------
www.thesnoman.com

 

P

PeterD

Guest

• Jan 31, 2006

• #4

On Mon, 30 Jan 2006 23:13:45 -0500, "Nobody" <[email protected]>
wrote:

>I would like some opinions about my idea of increasing the life of my
>automatic tranny. When I run up on slow changing lights or stoped traffic
>like at train tracks I like to shift my tranny into N. Do you feel this
>reduces wear or actually increases wear or does not make any difference.

Nope, more wear, not less. The act of engauging the transmission into
gear causes wear, but once in gear (and stopped) there is no wear
because the torque converter simply slips.

>
>Im thinking it helps because when you sit with your foot on the brake the
>wheels still want to pull a little even though the engine is at a slow idle.
>(friction = wear)
>
>

No friction, fluid slip in the torque converter. No wear.

If you really want to make your automatic last a long time:

1. Change the fluid every year without fail.
2. Invest in a fluid temp gauge and use it.
3, Never ever loan your truck to anyone.

 

P

PeterD

Guest

• Jan 31, 2006

• #5

On Tue, 31 Jan 2006 11:47:26 GMT, TheSnoMan <[email protected]> wrote:

>.boB wrote:
>>
>> The shifting back and forth will increase wear on those parts in
>> motion. Just put it in D and leave it there.
>>
>
>
>If it "wears" anything, it will be the linkage on the shifter.

Each time the clutches engauge there is wear on them, too.

 

T

TheSnoMan

Guest

• Jan 31, 2006

• #6

PeterD wrote:
> On Tue, 31 Jan 2006 11:47:26 GMT, TheSnoMan <[email protected]> wrote:
>
>> .boB wrote:
>>> The shifting back and forth will increase wear on those parts in
>>> motion. Just put it in D and leave it there.
>>>
>>
>> If it "wears" anything, it will be the linkage on the shifter.
>
> Each time the clutches engauge there is wear on them, too.


At a idle, none to speak of. I have a old plow truck that has gone from
forward to reverse tens of thousands on times in its 27 year life and
tranny still works fine but linkage is getting a bit worn.

--

-----------------
www.thesnoman.com

 

N

Nobody

Guest

• Jan 31, 2006

• #7

Thank you all for the advice. I guess for now on im going to put it in D and
leave it. Thats what I did with all my other automatics and I never had any
problems with them and I never serviced them neither. Mostly because they
were old and fairly cheap and I really did not care much untill I got
somthing newer and better looking. I assume thats true for most people
unless they have lots of money and like to buy a new one after 35K miles.
But thats a good thing because it has a better chance of ending up in
lessfortunate hands like me.

 

B

.boB

Guest

• Feb 1, 2006

• #8

TheSnoMan wrote:
> .boB wrote:
>
>> Nobody wrote:
>>
>>> I would like some opinions about my idea of increasing the life of my
>>> automatic tranny. When I run up on slow changing lights or stoped
>>> traffic like at train tracks I like to shift my tranny into N. Do you
>>> feel this reduces wear or actually increases wear or does not make
>>> any difference.
>>>
>>> Im thinking it helps because when you sit with your foot on the brake
>>> the wheels still want to pull a little even though the engine is at a
>>> slow idle. (friction = wear)
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>> The shifting back and forth will increase wear on those parts in
>> motion. Just put it in D and leave it there.
>>
>
>
> If it "wears" anything, it will be the linkage on the shifter.
>
Well, those would be the parts in motion.

--
..boB
On Order: 2006 FXDI, Red.
1997 HD FXDWG - Turbocharged Stolen 11/26/05 in Denver
1HD1GEL10VY3200010 CO License J5822Z
2001 Dodge Dakota QC 5.9/4x4/3.92
1966 Mustang Coupe - Daily Driver
1965 FFR Cobra - 427W EFI, Damn Fast.

 

P

PeterD

Guest

• Feb 1, 2006

• #9

On Tue, 31 Jan 2006 14:21:18 GMT, TheSnoMan <[email protected]> wrote:

>
>
>At a idle, none to speak of. I have a old plow truck that has gone from
>forward to reverse tens of thousands on times in its 27 year life and
>tranny still works fine but linkage is getting a bit worn.

I've had a few of those too. What I want is an electric shifter that
attaches to my plow controls, so I can shift and angle at the same
time... Now, thats something I'd pay for... <bg>

 

H

HarryHydro

Guest

• Feb 1, 2006

• #10

Hi:
I have a Dodge pickup and I always shift it manually, even though
it's an automatic. It's a work truck. The tranny makes alot of heat
when sitting in gear, but only the pump is doing any wearing at that
time. As long as the fluid is changed, and Immediately after an
overheat of the engine, the tranny should last a LONG time..