Flaming and treatment of new forummers

Widget · Mar 21, 2006

I've been thinking about this. Some people:

Can't spell or make themselves coherent
Don't even have the good grace to say thank you
Haven't the faintest idea about netiquette

But I would say give new posters a fighting chance before flaming them, perhaps by drawing out their thinking with some well-placed questions.

I think we should give thems enough rope to hang themselves first though. I'm no angel whatsover, and this is not directed personally, but looking back on a few recent posters I have these thoughts and feelings:

PROJECT90SPORT roll cage trouble - yep his name shouts, but he was flamed unneccesarily
Out door Paul Off road advise (sic) help me decideoff roading events - is in no way embarrassed by his own brilliance. Given a fair crack of the whip, nuff said.
Montyv6 new guy needs advice (lpg). Fair question, not well articulated - but he acknowledged that and was reasonable. Shameful reception from the Landyzone regulars.
Whereswaldo weird stuff you can find on ebay and others - flamed and deservedly so.
Len Drover duel fuel (sic) incoherent and funny (bearing in mind the diesel spark plug thread), but he never had a chance and I still have no idea whether it's a spoof or not. I suspect not though?!!

And guys - when did overt swearing become acceptable? A few acronyms and st*ars are OK surely?

Please post your comments and views - I may get a flaming myself but I invite your comment, whatever form that may take.

Guitarman · Mar 21, 2006

As a relative newby myself I feel quite lucky in that I haven't been flamed, ignored on occasion yes. It seems trying to join in with some of the banter that occurs on this site wont wash with the more established members, and I can appreciate that. As for the swearing, I don't find it offensive but am surprised there is no swear filter. Are there any moderators on this site?
I think it's fair to say that most car forums are "cliquey", I visit a few and it's mostly the same, viewing from the "outside".

slob · Mar 21, 2006

some people you can help and some are beyond help..if you get a stupid question then you can either ignore it or post a reply that will make them think abit ..or YOU could ask the questions that should have been clear in the original post. as for the swearing wtf is all that about?? we al know what f**k means so why not just type it?? a lot of things get answered but go unnoticed because it done via pm's. i know because i have help a few members this way. but if someone says can i fit these 355/10 x22 bear paw tyres on my steel series 2a rims then they should be publicly stoned and beaten about the soft body parts with a rear half shaft...
as for yer maun len drover..well.. he could be wheresdildo's twin

James · Mar 21, 2006

I strugle with spelling and make typos, however I do try hard and am not here for the spelling test, I did that at school and did not do very well. I am just looking for advice and help others where I can.

PS there are probably many errors in this text it's self.

GRUNT · Mar 21, 2006

Posts don't go "ignored", they go unanswered, I've had many posts go unanswered. But then I'm not paranoid. Most members help others to varieing degrees and I reckon all will help where possible. Would you prefer it if however many members there are replied with "Terribly sorry old boy but I don't know the answer to your query".

I don't think the forum is "cliquey", some members share more banter than others, some from what I can make out are mates, others have struck up frienships outside the forum. Good look to them it's none of my business, and I'm not paranoid.

Most of Widgets points about the way new larkers are treat in their threads is just banter, the roll cage one was simply digression, pub type bawdyness, and rather funny which is one of the better points of this forum, there are other forums that are full of uptight self important members which are downright boring and don't get half the "hits" as this one.

I don't care how well people can spell some can others can't. Unintelligable posts are unexcusable and there is also no excuse for typos, can't people read what they've written before they post it. If I haven't understood a post after the second or third reading then I give up.

Swearing became unacceptable with the Victorians until then it was an acceptable part of the English language.

Got to go Teabreak finished 10 minutes ago.

GRUNT · Mar 21, 2006

There are faults in the grammar and spelling of that last post will edit later I'm in a hurry

slob · Mar 21, 2006

ere grunt maybe we should post twice to each question.one for us 'lads' and once for the 'girls and others'

slob · Mar 21, 2006

i agree with what was said about flaming, i think we should be really polite to everyone and this toilet houmour has to stop!!!!!
someday you, grunt, will be the butt of someone's joke. and we'll see how you like it. or maybe widget could vet all posts to see if we can have a pop at them or if we should behave.
i sugest a points system. 1 point for each spelling or punctuation error. 5 points for asking a dumb question with a 3 point rebate if it is within yer first 5 posts.100 points for each use of 'lol' ..and 5000 point for using deisel instead of diesel.
anyone with more than 8 points is open to flaming or general piff taking

Guitarman · Mar 21, 2006

Does anybody, apart from Slob, know who Alex Havrey is?

How was that?

slob · Mar 21, 2006

grunt does

slob · Mar 21, 2006

now if you was eddjamacated like wot we is, you'd realise that grunt has a line from an obscure song as his signature. now i think its from an alex harvey song but i can't remember the title.

Guitarman · Mar 21, 2006

Sensational Alex Harvey?

slob · Mar 21, 2006

well it were actually the sensational alex harvey band but yeah thats the dude

fredlander · Mar 21, 2006

Guitarman said:
Does anybody, apart from Slob, know who Alex Havrey is?

How was that?

Wasn't it the Alex Harvey Band?, i'm sure i liked them

but i lost most of the '70s

my mates said i had a good time,....and my 1st. wife left me,

Guitarman · Mar 21, 2006

Not all bad then!

fredlander · Mar 21, 2006

So what was the big hit guitarman?????

Guitarman · Mar 21, 2006

I want to say Abracadabra, but I'm fairly sure that's wrong.

GRUNT · Mar 21, 2006

I was going to rant on a bit more but can't be arsed. after all who am I to complain, I'm not your Dad. Do as you will. I've more to worry about, I've got a poorly landrover, not that you lot care you heartless set of ****s.

By the way did you know that a **** is what the ones that came before us called a sheath for a sythe.

The Alex Harvey Band or The Sensational Alex Harvey Band. Saw both several times. The Best thing to come out of Scotland except whiskey of course. Thought you'd get that one Slob. Your turn.

slob · Mar 21, 2006

i did i did but i wasn't gonna use the 'P' word incase i upset someone

fredlander · Mar 21, 2006

I thought the best thing to come outa Scotland was the skids, see them B4 they were famous at a pub called the Bungalow, opposite the lorry park in Paisley, i remember it well because i had the sh*ts all the way home after a curry, stopped at every service area between Hamilton and newport pagnell, and even once on the hard shoulder.

Flaming and treatment of new forummers

New Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Similar threads