tom1979

tom1979

Well-Known Member
Full Member
Hi all does anyone know if 5w30 oil is ok in the td5 engins on a disco? Haynes manual says 5w40 or 5w50 but I have a td5 defender as well which uses 5w30, along with transit, focus, Astra vans etc so I have whole drums of 5w30.

Seeing as it's thinner than 5w40, I would have thought it would be ok - can anyone confirm?
 
Last edited:
Many thanks I thought it was as that's what I use in defender, but this is a 10P engine and disco is 15P so wondered if they were slightly different.

Cheers
Tom
 
The 40 is for the higher end of the engine range so if you are towing alot or high speed or heavy off roading it will give you better protection, O and I miss out driving across the desert ! :rofl:
 
5w-30 is good for TD5 up to ambient temps of, on average 30°c.

5w-40 is good for TD5 up to ambient temps of, on average 40°c +


What do you imagine is the average ambient temp in the UK during summer?
 
there is other thing which is mostly neglected, not just the oil thickness/viscosity is important... there are specially engineered oils for EUI(electronic unit injector) equipped engines(as the Td5), using the dedicated stuff would prolonge the engine's life
 
sierrafery said:
there is other thing which is mostly neglected, not just the oil thickness/viscosity is important... there are specially engineered oils for EUI(electronic unit injector) equipped engines(as the Td5), using the dedicated stuff would prolong the engine's life
Click to expand...



Hi Fery, I've not come across that before, can you give me an example?

The injectors themselves are obviously lubricated by the diesel fuel, so where does the engine oil aspect come into play? It's certainly not specified by LR.


Dave
 
thebiglad said:
Hi Fery, I've not come across that before, can you give me an example?

The injectors themselves are obviously lubricated by the diesel fuel, so where does the engine oil aspect come into play? It's certainly not specified by LR.


Dave
Click to expand...

they will be the one's that are better at getting into the injection loom:D
 
thebiglad said:
Hi Fery, I've not come across that before, can you give me an example?

The injectors themselves are obviously lubricated by the diesel fuel, so where does the engine oil aspect come into play? It's certainly not specified by LR.


Dave
Click to expand...

hi Dave, for example(scroll down to the description) COMMA DIESEL PD 5W40 FULLY SYNTHETIC 5 LITRE OIL | eBay the Td5 is also this kind of PD engine, these oils have a lower electrical conductivity than 'ordinary' oils as the injector solenoids and the loom are in the oil
 
thebiglad said:
Hi Fery, I've not come across that before, can you give me an example?

The injectors themselves are obviously lubricated by the diesel fuel, so where does the engine oil aspect come into play? It's certainly not specified by LR.


Dave
Click to expand...

cam and follower are under great pressure
 
How important is the ACEA number?

The Haynes manual says to use ACEA A1 or A2; I have never even looked at these before but notice that the oil we use is 5w30 - API CH-4, MACK T-9, ACEA E4, VOLVO VDS-2, MB228.5, SCANIA LDF, MAN M3277, MTU TYPE 3, MACK EO-L.
(Exol Taurus UHPD 5w/30 Synthetic Long drain commercial oil)
 
seen that you guys have recommended 5W40 but interenet thinks 10W30, whats the difference, why is there a difference and does it matter? x
 
GypsyBee said:
seen that you guys have recommended 5W40 but interenet thinks 10W30, whats the difference, why is there a difference and does it matter? x
Click to expand...

answered my own question :'D haha ...... "10w40 is thicker than 5w40, ONLY when cold. At operating temperature it is exactly the same. Multi-viscosity oils with a lower W number are specifically designed to flow better, and thus lubricate better, at very low temperatures. There is no need to use a 5w-40 if the vehicle only requires 10w-40."
 
just thought this little bit of info was good for anyone like me who is a complete baby when it comes to car knowledge.
Q- whats best 10w40 or 5w40
A- "10w40 is a slightly thicker (viscosity) oil than 5w40, a lower viscosity oil protectsbetter from cold, it's also recommended for new engines with very tight tolerances, but pour it into an older engine and the piston rings will struggle to keep it out of the combustion chamber and you'll burn oil."
 
Discodevon said:
Total quartz 7000 10w40 every time for a td5 and 300tdi
Click to expand...
I hope you don't think that those two engines are the same.... did you ever hear how a PD/EUI engine is built and working? ... i think not as long as you compare it with a 300Tdi :confused: ... there are special oils for PD engines if you want the best.. if you just want to have oil in it to not be stressed that the engine is not lubricated then yes... put what ever sh*t you want or go back untill post #7, read carefully again maybe you'll understand and gain some thoughtfulness to not recommend unproper oils to others
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Chazb5046
Disco 2 Is this safe? TD5 5w30 change to 5w40
Replies
9
Views
3K
tilly2
T
The Wombat
Discovery Td5 Instrument cluster config or programming
Replies
5
Views
542
sierrafery
sierrafery
H
Discovery TD5 engine starts shaking occasionally when started
2
Replies
39
Views
2K
sierrafery
sierrafery
J
engine cuts out at high revs, eml on td5
Replies
2
Views
304
Tim4x4
Tim4x4
R
Discovery 4 TDV6 - shuddering engine, no acceleration/won’t rev
Replies
7
Views
1K
tyregeezer
tyregeezer