Saint.V8 said:
I never implied you didn't know the marble test as you had mentioned it earlier in the thread (as you kindly note above)....just trying to stop you needlessly removing a potentially unremovable top!
Click to expand...

This is getting confusing now :)

That was a video of MY marble test on the rad in question filmed yesterday. So I know there is a lack of baffle. What I don't know is if it was there and has broken, or was never there. That would be the most interesting thing - although it wouldn't change the fact that I need a new rad.

A camera would save the effort I suppose as if the baffle had failed, it would be in there. If it was never there, it would be equally obvious. But I don't have one...

Nik
 
NikTheGeek said:
This is getting confusing now :)

That was a video of MY marble test on the rad in question filmed yesterday. So I know there is a lack of baffle. What I don't know is if it was there and has broken, or was never there. That would be the most interesting thing - although it wouldn't change the fact that I need a new rad.

A camera would save the effort I suppose as if the baffle had failed, it would be in there. If it was never there, it would be equally obvious. But I don't have one...

Nik
Click to expand...
If the baffle was there but had broken off it would come out with the marble unless it fell out earlier.
 
Nik the rad has no baffle. Whether it ever had one or it has broken off is beside the point, it is no good to you. It has either never had one or failed, either way it should be warranted. Ring the people you bought it off and tell them what has been said on here. They are storemen they don't have a bloody clue how it is supposed to be configured. They are selling parts that are incorrect and not fit for purpose the ball is in their court. If they argue the toss mention trading standards.
 
wammers said:
nik the rad has no baffle. Whether it ever had one or it has broken off is beside the point, it is no good to you. It has either never had one or failed, either way it should be warranted. Ring the people you bought it off and tell them what has been said on here. They are storemen they don't have a bloody clue how it is supposed to be configured. They are selling parts that are incorrect and not fit for purpose the ball is in their court. If they argue the toss mention trading standards.
Click to expand...
+1:)
 
Update: AL Services have been straight on it this morning. Offered to post out a replacement FOC - I'd already ordered a replacement from Island though. No problem, post the old one back for inspection and I'll get a full refund, inc P&P - and possibly some of the labour costs back.

Considering they only found out about it a few hours ago, AL Services support has been spot on so far...

Fingers crossed the replacement from Island is ok :)

Nik
 
Datatek said:
I can see what looks like a small plastic piece that looks like an attempt at a baffle:rolleyes:
Click to expand...

I spotted that and wondered if that's what the baffle should be fastened to or if that's what the baffle WAS fastened to and it's now in bits somewhere in my cooling system :)
 
NikTheGeek said:
I spotted that and wondered if that's what the baffle should be fastened to or if that's what the baffle WAS fastened to and it's now in bits somewhere in my cooling system :)
Click to expand...
It would have been an integral part of the plastic moulding, either the mold is badly made or the cavity for the baffle has become blocked and poor quality control means it has not been picked up.
 
NikTheGeek said:
I spotted that and wondered if that's what the baffle should be fastened to or if that's what the baffle WAS fastened to and it's now in bits somewhere in my cooling system :)
Click to expand...

Why did you not stick the scope down to it and take a closer look?
 
Grit Valve said:
Nik what make was the dodgy one and what make did you put in in the end ??
Click to expand...

It wasn't a make as such, it was a part number as sold by well known suppliers and this was supplied to the garage by a well known supplier.

The one I fitted last night was a Nissens one supplied by Island 4x4 and that is fine.

Nik
 
Last edited:
Sometime ago I had a Nissens radiator fitted and I did the marble test, but I didn't use a big marble, in fact I used a small M6 nut that came through the other side. This convinced me that the radiator was no good and I replaced it.

Reading this thread prompted me to make a video inspection of the Nissens rad that I still had lying around. What I found out is that it does indeed have a central baffle, but there's a small space between it and the aluminum that's big enough for a small nut to pass through. So, I now believe that the rad is good.

For anyone interested about what the inside of the rad looks like, here's my take at it:
P38 Nissens radiator - showing the central baffle - YouTube

Cheers to Nick for the inspiration to check this with a small usb endoscope camera.
 
mcapinha said:
Sometime ago I had a Nissens radiator fitted and I did the marble test, but I didn't use a big marble, in fact I used a small M6 nut that came through the other side. This convinced me that the radiator was no good and I replaced it.

Reading this thread prompted me to make a video inspection of the Nissens rad that I still had lying around. What I found out is that it does indeed have a central baffle, but there's a small space between it and the aluminum that's big enough for a small nut to pass through. So, I now believe that the rad is good.

For anyone interested about what the inside of the rad looks like, here's my take at it:
P38 Nissens radiator - showing the central baffle - YouTube

Cheers to Nick for the inspiration to check this with a small usb endoscope camera.
Click to expand...

I think the inspiration for that came from me actually. :D:D
 
Last edited:
mcapinha said:
Sometime ago I had a Nissens radiator fitted and I did the marble test, but I didn't use a big marble, in fact I used a small M6 nut that came through the other side. This convinced me that the radiator was no good and I replaced it.

Reading this thread prompted me to make a video inspection of the Nissens rad that I still had lying around. What I found out is that it does indeed have a central baffle, but there's a small space between it and the aluminum that's big enough for a small nut to pass through. So, I now believe that the rad is good.

For anyone interested about what the inside of the rad looks like, here's my take at it:
P38 Nissens radiator - showing the central baffle - YouTube

Cheers to Nick for the inspiration to check this with a small usb endoscope camera.
Click to expand...
its funny you mention that as I have a nissens I phoned the supplier and asked where they were bought it in bulk ect and waS told they are supplied by Allmakes in bulk , now what confuses me is that nissens are a company of there own are they now supplying Allmakes ?

I didn't check my rad when I installed it as I didn't know about the baffle senecio , but now I have the nano I can see the temp seems high and on checking the rad it seems cool down below copaired to the much higher temp at both hosed and along the complete top .

I have explained the situation to my supplier and if said baffle is missing it will be resolved .
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

enjoi
P38A Going through radiators- not overheating
2 3
Replies
55
Views
3K
kermit_rr
kermit_rr
F
2001 P38 2.5 Diesel EKA Via NANOCOM
2
Replies
35
Views
1K
Datatek
Datatek
J
P38 DSE Auto intermittent lack of power after vehicle has been hot
Replies
4
Views
225
JT_spark
J
M
Evoque Blind spot not working just a yellow spot in the left mirror it some time comes on and off.
Replies
18
Views
968
moonraker 3958
M
D
P38 in need of some love
Replies
7
Views
655
stuu
stuu