maniac · Jul 11, 2009

Hi Guys Newby here
Bought a 2002 TD4 3 months ago with 36k on the clock (genuine). Broke down returning from Nottingham and told it's water pump. Had it brought back to my local mechanic (not a Landy guy) who reckons the engine has to be taken out and it's going to cost around £500+.

Is this about normal? Haynes reckons you can access the pump by raising the car and dropping the engine to access the pump via the front offside wheel arch.

This is my first landy (and first 4x4) so don't know the score!

:5bdriving::5bdriving:

disco_mikey · Jul 11, 2009

Its tight, but can be done as Haynes says by removing the engine mount and lowering the engine...

maniac · Jul 11, 2009

cheers disco_mikey

I mentioned Haynes to my mech - not a positive response.. his view was that if I wanted to do it that way, he'd arrange to have it dropped off at my place, otherwise, he'd do it the way he knows!

JonFre · Jul 11, 2009

maniac said:

Hi Guys Newby here
Bought a 2002 TD4 3 months ago with 36k on the clock (genuine). Broke down returning from Nottingham and told it's water pump. Had it brought back to my local mechanic (not a Landy guy) who reckons the engine has to be taken out and it's going to cost around £500+.

Is this about normal? Haynes reckons you can access the pump by raising the car and dropping the engine to access the pump via the front offside wheel arch.

This is my first landy (and first 4x4) so don't know the score!

Click to expand...

maniac said:
Did you buy from a dealer ? Warranty?

maniac · Jul 11, 2009

JonFre said:
maniac said:

Hi Guys Newby here
Bought a 2002 TD4 3 months ago with 36k on the clock (genuine). Broke down returning from Nottingham and told it's water pump. Had it brought back to my local mechanic (not a Landy guy) who reckons the engine has to be taken out and it's going to cost around £500+.

Is this about normal? Haynes reckons you can access the pump by raising the car and dropping the engine to access the pump via the front offside wheel arch.

This is my first landy (and first 4x4) so don't know the score!

Click to expand...

maniac said:

Did you buy from a dealer ? Warranty?

Click to expand...

Unfortunately not from a dealer - from someone I know quite well who had just had it serviced and MOT'd by a Landy dealer. Old story... caveat emptor!

freelance · Jul 11, 2009

he who does the job chooses the method, but if it can be done without
removing the engine then that would be my favourite, don't forget haynes manwell written with home mechanics in mind

CJK · Jul 12, 2009

Done this job on my 2002 TD4. It is possible from underneath without removing the whole engine. Tight and getting to some of the fasteners does require raising and then lowering the engine to get spanner room! But very do-able.
Think there is a procedure in the RAVE cd, but that involves removing a lot of the turbo plumbing which I didn't find necessary!

Chris.

Chaser · Jul 12, 2009

maniac said:
cheers disco_mikey

I mentioned Haynes to my mech - not a positive response.. his view was that if I wanted to do it that way, he'd arrange to have it dropped off at my place, otherwise, he'd do it the way he knows!

It sounds to like this guy is going to rip you off, nobody in their right mind would completely remove the engine.
You only have to support the engine with a hoist or even a jack and remove the engine steady and hydramount so you can lower the engine for access to the pump bolts.

maniac · Jul 17, 2009

Cheers guys - thanks for the input - looks like I shall be needing to find a new garage for landy works. Shame, I've used this guy for years - drink with him in the local and have never once felt I was being ripped off. Clearly, however, he and landys don't go together!

nb. Checked out price with Stratstones - they would charge in excess of £800

mikeong · Jul 22, 2009

maniac said:
Cheers guys - thanks for the input - looks like I shall be needing to find a new garage for landy works. Shame, I've used this guy for years - drink with him in the local and have never once felt I was being ripped off. Clearly, however, he and landys don't go together!

nb. Checked out price with Stratstones - they would charge in excess of £800

By the way how many kms before we need to replace the pump?Is the pump impeller made from plastics like beemers?

maniac

New Member

disco_mikey

Active Member

maniac

New Member

JonFre

Active Member

maniac

New Member

freelance

Well-Known Member

CJK

Member

Chaser

New Member

maniac

New Member

mikeong

New Member

Similar threads