Wee dregor

Member

• Jun 4, 2023

• #1

Hi looking for advice and your thoughts I have a whole second hand engine, should I swap whole engine that's perfectly timed into freelander and take out my bottom end , or split used engine and use cylinder head onto my own bottom half which is still in car and rebuild with new hg second hand engine has no hgf .I'd like to inspect second hand but don't want to create more problems whats your thoughts reason for change cylinder head had gone in car but bottom end has had new sealed liners thanks

 

A

Alex1000

Active Member

• Jun 5, 2023

• #2

Honestly, if you have a known good 2nd hand engine, I'd be inclined to replace the complete unit. Changing heads always results in a lot more work than you think and so much more that can go wrong.

But thatis my opinion, and i'm not a full time grease monkey. Only going by the times I changed a head or replaced an engine..

 

Wee dregor

Member

• Jun 5, 2023

• #3

Alex1000 said:

Honestly, if you have a known good 2nd hand engine, I'd be inclined to replace the complete unit. Changing heads always results in a lot more work than you think and so much more that can go wrong.

But thatis my opinion, and i'm not a full time grease monkey. Only going by the times I changed a head or replaced an engine..

Click to expand...

Unfortunately don't know the history of engine only the milage and is it possible that i could change whole engine for head gasket to go in a few months even though it doesn't have hgf at the moment this is my dilemma split engine for new head gasket on block that's already in Car is it more work to do complete swap

 

pwood999

Well-Known Member

Full Member

• Jun 5, 2023

• #4

Depends on what engine ?

 

Nodge68

Well-Known Member

• Jun 5, 2023

• #5

What vehicle and engine is it?

 

Wee dregor

Member

• Jun 5, 2023

• #6

1.8 k series petrol freelander 1 2004

 

Nodge68

Well-Known Member

• Jun 5, 2023

• #7

Wee dregor said:

1.8 k series petrol freelander 1 2004

Click to expand...

In my experience, it's better to build a reliable k series, rather than trust an unknown unit off eBay. Or get one from an MG 6, which is pretty similar, and apparently more reliable.

 

Wee dregor

Member

• Jun 5, 2023

• #8

Nodge68 said:

In my experience, it's better to build a reliable k series, rather than trust an unknown unit off eBay. Or get one from an MG 6, which is pretty similar, and apparently more reliable.

Click to expand...

I'm going to split it that's it decided on that advice at least you can see what sort of life span this engine has had and any traces of overheating and check the liners for any evidence and can change hg cheers nodge68