aevans692 · Apr 9, 2020

Hello all ..

a little follow on from my bk door post , I have decided to get the weight of the spare off the bk door , think one of these swing away's would be a good idea ...?

which ones are good , which are bad ? , are the brit-part one awful ?? are the Raptor ones worth the extra money ??

has any of you guys fitted one , ant tips or hints , and which did you buy ... ?

I will be fitting it to my defender 110 td5 , 98 if that makes any diff ....

cheers guys ..

doriz · Apr 9, 2020

I bought a Mantec swing away, well build and easy to fit. The only reservation is the daft tubular slider that anchors the thing to the back door. Either way I'm chuffed I got that big heavy tyre of the flimsy framed rear door.

aevans692 · Apr 9, 2020

I will have a look at them , one I havnt seen ...

lynall · Apr 10, 2020

Britpart one been on my 90 for a few years now, and it was 2nd hand off of my mate who had it on his 90.
All the paint/coating is still on it.
It does not rattle, it used to, but I cannot remember what I did to stop it, but it would have been simple/cheap, as I am tight!
It has grease nipples.
Fiddly fcuk getting the backing plate into the rear xmember for the bolts to screw into.

aevans692 · Apr 11, 2020

I keep looking at the raptor swing away , these look to be HD , wondering if anyone has fitted one , If they are worth the extra money over one of the cheaper brit-part one ..

lynall · Apr 11, 2020

aevans692 said:
I keep looking at the raptor swing away , these look to be HD , wondering if anyone has fitted one , If they are worth the extra money over one of the cheaper brit-part one ..

The raptor looks nice, but I have a few reservations,
1, the top and bottom rose joints are totally reliant on that bolt staying tight, and the plates the bolt passes through not twisting
2, that little rose jointed rod that connects the carrier to the door does not look to heavy duty, again single bolt either end through a single plate.
On the plus side the xmember plate looks quite substantial where it bolts on.

The Britpart one,
1, the pivot bolts have a plate top and bottom so cannot wring/twist even if they come loose
2, the door connection is much more substantial.

Never thought I would praise britpart!

aevans692 · Apr 11, 2020

thats interesting points I hadn't thought about it like this ..

aevans692 · Apr 11, 2020

one of the other things I need to consider , is that I sometimes use a motorcycle ( trials bike) dave cooper rack fitted to my tow bar , I was wondering if the wheel would stand more proud from the back with the use of a swing away ?

If the back wheel sits further back away from the door , it might prevent me fitting my bike on the rack ....

lightning · Apr 11, 2020

You can fit a tow ball spacer which may be enough to compensate for the wheel being a bit further out.

aevans692 · Apr 11, 2020

thats a thought, id have to check to see if the rack mounting bracket could take a spacer ...

lynall · Apr 11, 2020

aevans692 said:
one of the other things I need to consider , is that I sometimes use a motorcycle ( trials bike) dave cooper rack fitted to my tow bar , I was wondering if the wheel would stand more proud from the back with the use of a swing away ?

If the back wheel sits further back away from the door , it might prevent me fitting my bike on the rack ....

My tyre touched the door skin, and i had to pack the studs out with washers for it to clear,not many 3 or 4 Iirc, so if you had door mounted spare before, you wont have an issue

doriz · Apr 11, 2020

This is Mantec on mine - iirc the spare wheel sits very close to the tow ball when I put my boat trailer on though I'm confident my Thule tow ball bike rack still fits well.

lightning · Apr 11, 2020

Fit the spacer like on mine (picture above)

Brown · Apr 11, 2020

I've got one like this
http://www.extreme4x4.co.uk/Store/Rear-Wheel-Carriers/rear-wheel-carriers-1
It's handy as it has a place to put the Hi Lift jack too. It's galvanised under the black paint.

doriz · Apr 11, 2020

Brown said:
I've got one like this
http://www.extreme4x4.co.uk/Store/Rear-Wheel-Carriers/rear-wheel-carriers-1
It's handy as it has a place to put the Hi Lift jack too. It's galvanised under the black paint.

That's the downside with mine. I think it has some really poor plasticote which will undoubtedly crack and rust in time.

Brown · Apr 11, 2020

doriz said:
That's the downside with mine. I think it has some really poor plasticote which will undoubtedly crack and rust in time.

Well, it might be hard to get paint to stick to it, but at least when it flakes off all you can see is zinc, rather than a uniform finish of ferrous oxide to blend in with the rest of the Land Rover. I have an auxiliary fuel tank that goes under the rear wing, which I fitted around the same time, and the brackets for that rust amazingly quickly. They make the Land Rover chassis look quite durable by comparison.

Blaven · Apr 11, 2020

I’ve got the Nakatenenga on mine. Not cheap I admit but great quality

doriz · Apr 12, 2020

Blaven said:
got the Nakatenenga

Is that another way of saying I've got the bollox swing away spare wheel carrier?

Blaven · Apr 12, 2020

doriz said:
Is that another way of saying I've got the bollox swing away spare wheel carrier?

Now,now !

aevans692 · Apr 12, 2020

I’m not sure if I’d get the clearance , I don’t think a spacer would work as there is a lot of weight on it .. when the bike is on the bk it’s pretty close to the spare wheel

I might have to pass on the swing away

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Active Member

Attachments

Similar threads