BravoNovember · Mar 24, 2019

Trying to do the drive shaft oil seals on my disco two, as always it’s a mission!

Hub nut won’t budge, it doesn’t look like it has been staked by whoever put it on so I don’t think it’s that.

Breaker, jack under breaker, hitting socket with a mallet, running out of options.

If I get the torch on it and heat it will I b*gger up anyththing else in the hub like the bearings and all that?

Or my only other option is to try and drill and split the nut, but access is limited by the raised crown bit on the hub.

I’m open to suggestions.

Sorry if it’s a proper noob question!

Beneagles · Mar 24, 2019

Longer lever - stick a scaff pole on the breaker!

Si Click · Mar 24, 2019

3/4" breaker with scaff pole (1/2" may well snap), or a really good impact wrench able to cope with > 400NM. Good quality rechargeable ones are light and small, but expensive; alternatively mains powered ones are more powerful and start at around £60, but are less useful when access is restricted.

Bobsticle · Mar 24, 2019

Cold chisel and lumpy.

beanwood · Mar 24, 2019

Torque multiplier, or heavy duty Impact wrench (I now have both!!)
It amazed me how easily it took mine off after I'd snapped a 3/4 breaker bar.
Whereabouts are you?

Bobdog · Mar 24, 2019

3/4" breaker with scaff tube, touching or near the ground in direction of travel, then 1st or reverse gear depending on which side you are doing and drive slowly off...

Mine came off with a 1/2" breaker and an old trampoline pole over it (it was bending like fook without it) then I stood on it and it cracked the nut.
Edit- don't forget to put the wheel back on before trying the above...

BravoNovember · Mar 24, 2019

beanwood said:
Torque multiplier, or heavy duty Impact wrench (I now have both!!)
It amazed me how easily it took mine off after I'd snapped a 3/4 breaker bar.
Whereabouts are you?

I’m in the worlds of Wiltshire.

Funny enough I had a look at some impact wrenches today whilst I was out, can’t afford til payday lol!

neilly · Mar 24, 2019

BravoNovember said:
I’m in the worlds of Wiltshire.

Funny enough I had a look at some impact wrenches today whilst I was out, can’t afford til payday lol!

If you use a breaker bar, then support the extension bar on an axle stand , it makes applying the torque to undo it a little more controlled.

Cheers

BravoNovember · Mar 24, 2019

Right I’ve got seven feet of scaf pole from my mates garden, this will not defeat me lol!

I’ll give it a nudge with the 1/2 inch breaker, if it snaps it will be 3/4 inch time on payday.

Thanks for the post so far guys, I appreciate the help!

neilly · Mar 24, 2019

BravoNovember said:
Right I’ve got seven feet of scaf pole from my mates garden, this will not defeat me lol!

I’ll give it a nudge with the 1/2 inch breaker, if it snaps it will be 3/4 inch time on payday.

Thanks for the post so far guys, I appreciate the help!

I hope you are using a 6 sided socket as well.

Cheers

Si Click · Mar 24, 2019

If you have problems keeping the socket on the nut with a long breaker + scaff get a helper to lie on their back and push the socket on with their foot.

BravoNovember · Mar 24, 2019

neilly said:
I hope you are using a 6 sided socket as well.

Cheers

Yep, I’ve hear not to use the ones with more sides with a lot of torque. I imagine it’s to spread the load force over the whole side rather than just the corners? (Go easy on the noob if I’m wrong lol).

Pretty much gonna use this one (pic)

freelance · Mar 24, 2019

Seven foot, on a half inch breaker bar, it’s going to end in tears !

BravoNovember · Mar 24, 2019

freelance said:
Seven foot, on a half inch breaker bar, it’s going to end in tears !

I can cut the tube down if it’s too much of a beast???

I might have a chat with the head of motor vehicle at the college I work at, see if he will lend me a 3/4 bar and socket. You have me worrying now with mental images of snapping bars and flying shrapnel eeeeek.

BravoNovember · Mar 24, 2019

freelance said:
Seven foot, on a half inch breaker bar, it’s going to end in tears !

Nice avatar btw, gotta love a Case!

bluedog333 · Mar 24, 2019

BravoNovember said:
I can cut the tube down if it’s too much of a beast???

Just hold it half way down it’s length, work your way along the pole until something gives.

kevstar · Mar 24, 2019

I've not long snapped a snap on 1/2 breaker bar removing wheel nuts id be very surprized if your bar survives this
3/4" set took them off without an issue id wait until you have a decent tool for the job.

beanwood · Mar 24, 2019

BravoNovember said:
I’m in the worlds of Wiltshire.

OK.....Well Wiltshire is a fairly large place. Is where you live a secret??
If you want to borrow the multiplier, you're welcome, (It makes it pi$$ easy) but without knowing how far away you are...

BravoNovember · Mar 24, 2019

beanwood said:
OK.....Well Wiltshire is a fairly large place. Is where you live a secret??
If you want to borrow the multiplier, you're welcome, (It makes it pi$$ easy) but without knowing how far away you are...

Lol sorry I’m in Trowbridge, that’s very kind of you to offer! Cheers. I would like to take you up on that.

beanwood · Mar 24, 2019

OK. let me know if you want to borrow it.
I work in Bath, and have a colleague who lives in Trowbridge and he MAY be able to assist with transport, but I'm not back to work until Wednesday or Thursday.

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

De Villes Advocaat

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Attachments

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Active Member

Active Member

Similar threads