stuartroger · Apr 8, 2013

Hi Guys,
I have a Freelander 1 which is causing me a little greif.
The car has a knocking noise seriouly mechanical when I reverse with right hand down (knock 3/4 times) it also repeats itself when I drive forward following this situation. I occassionally get the noise when I turn right a traffic lights or at a road junction especially a slow speeds. The noise reminds me of when I had a Mini 1 with defective cv joints
I removed the diff outer plate on Saturday and inspected the gears no obvious missing teeth, no bits in the oil, minor swarf on filler plug magnet.
Checked all suspension mountings no obvious play etc. Replaced defective diff mounting.
Checked CV joints for wear, minor wear only not visually inspected cv joint.
New tyres all round so diff windup is not a problem.
Checked and had checked vicous coupling and this is ok.
Any help please
Stuartroger new member

gareth123 · Apr 8, 2013

I was going to suggest front diff mount but you say you have changed one of the mounts - which one?

hsp · Apr 8, 2013

agree, sounds like diff mounts, replace the other two also.

teddywood1 · Apr 8, 2013

are you sure it is not the ird

mjrimmer · Apr 9, 2013

teddywood1 said:
are you sure it is not the ird

Or front cv......noise travels in perculiar ways on a hippo.

WLJayne · Apr 9, 2013

Cracked sub frame mount perhaps

?

stuartroger · Apr 11, 2013

gareth123 said:
I was going to suggest front diff mount but you say you have changed one of the mounts - which one?

Hi Gareth 123,
Thanks for reply, mount changed front, the noise is definatly a cracking or crunch when I move slowly on lock forwards or backwards.
It reminds me od the days that I drove a Mini mk 1 when the CV joints would crack.
Not sure whether to start replacing the driveshafts starting with the r/hand side and see what happens.....any thoughts?
stuartroger

stuartroger · Apr 11, 2013

hsp said:
agree, sounds like diff mounts, replace the other two also.

Hi HSP,
Thanks for the reply
No damage or play on other mounts all checked and found to be sound, the noise is not a banging as with defective mounts it is a definite cracking or crunching just like the noise I recall the CV joints of a MK 1 Mini.

stuartroger · Apr 11, 2013

teddywood1 said:
are you sure it is not the ird

Hi teddywood1,
Thanks for the reply.
The IRD has been checked on a number of occassions, like turning with a set of stilsons; checking for the IRD being hot which it does not get hot; driving upto 10 miles an hour taking the car out gear and freewheeling the car just freewheels no resitance of any magnitude.
I am seriously looking at stating to replace the drive shafts starting with the righthand side

stuartroger · Apr 11, 2013

mjrimmer said:
Or front cv......noise travels in perculiar ways on a hippo.

MJRimmer,

Thanks for the reply, my guess has been todate the R/H rear driveshat inbord CV joint.
I am considering to start to replace the drive shafts starting with that one
I did replace one on the front R/H side about 6 months ago due to a fault on the reluctor ring causing 3 amigos to light up

stuartroger · Apr 11, 2013

WLJayne said:
Cracked sub frame mount perhaps ?

Hi WLJAYNE,

Thanks for the reply, the independant landrover garage that I use from time to time started with that view some 5 months ago and undertook a repair to the R/H side rear sub frame mountings by welding in additional plates..............has not cure it and still looking

CJK · May 30, 2013

Did you ever get this snag fixed, as I now seem to have exactly this.
I'm told the rear diff is f**ked and needs replacing.

Thanks,

Chris

CJK · May 31, 2013

In case anyone else is searching through these snags, mine was due to the prop shaft bolts not being quite tight enough on to the diff flange.
That has fixed these noises for me!

Chris.

Def90v8 · Jun 1, 2013

Hi it's 100% the rear sub frame mount on o/s r cracked and pulling out of body
The cheapest fix a I have done a couple of times is to weld the sub frame to the body other wise gets very expensive replacing the box section lr do a repair section
If u look at the right hand o/s body where the bolt is u will see cracking
When loaded up on lock this opens up and moves
Caused by seized vcu
Later cars were strengthened at that point
Hope this helps

CJK · Jun 1, 2013

It all those symptoms, but no cracks found.
Bolts on prop shaft to rear diff input shaft tightened, all noise gone!

It went in to have the welding done....... But it wasn't that!

Chris.

CJK · Jun 1, 2013

Following your guidance, I've had a bloody good look and poke about where you said and I can see a few cracks, just!
Looks like I need to find a better Land Rover Specialist, but to be fair, he is a real Land Rover specialist!
But there were lots of frequent little creaking noises and occasional one loud click, the frequent noises have gone, just the occasional loud click now! So prop shaft bolts could have been a contributing factor!
So thanks for your advice.

Chris.

stuartroger

New Member

gareth123

Active Member

hsp

Member

teddywood1

Well-Known Member

mjrimmer

Active Member

WLJayne

Well-Known Member

stuartroger

New Member

stuartroger

New Member

stuartroger

New Member

stuartroger

New Member

stuartroger

New Member

CJK

Member

CJK

Member

Def90v8

New Member

CJK

Member

CJK

Member

Similar threads