I wonder if the haldex went because the tyres were being changed one at a time instead of the tyres on the front/rear axels being changed together

It’s very possible.

According to the invoice it was fitted in December 2022 at 43k miles.
In theory, it should now be good for another few years - either that or the car continued to rack up big bills so the owner cut their loses and got rid.

You pays your money, you takes your chances I guess.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2437.jpeg
    IMG_2437.jpeg
    389.7 KB · Views: 17
Last edited:
Is a main dealer service history worth a premium?

It would ‘explain’ and command a premium, certainly.
In theory, a vehicle going to the main dealer will get genuine parts, fitted correctly, on time, and will receive updates etc. Importantly, it will also get the correct fluids used. Main dealer servicing is more expensive, and so a car can carry a premium for it.

The vehicle has only the first 3 years main dealer, which I dare say was just to protect their warranty at the time, so I don’t think it can command any sort of premium for a ‘main dealer’ service history.

The service interval history it does have is good, and a regular garage is at least a good indicator. Check reviews of the garage used perhaps… is it reputable?
 
According to the invoice it was fitted in December 2022 at 43k miles.
In theory, it should now be good for another few years
It shouldn’t have needed a new Haldex in the first place, not at 40k miles.

I noticed on the invoice it said ‘refit new Haldex and refill with oil’… now that could just be missing detail and it is referring to the diff rather than the Haldex, but the Haldex takes a particular fluid only, and it is never referred to as ‘oil’.


Ultimately, all you can do is get it checked by someone that knows these vehicles on your behalf, but I think the consensus is that it seems quite expensive for what it is.


Same year, better spec, in NI, for 3k less…

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202410195386509?advertising-location=at_cars&aggregatedTrim=&atmobcid=soc5&body-type=&colour=&fromsra&fuel-type=&make=Land Rover&model=Freelander 2&radius=200&sort=relevance&transmission=&year-to=2024
 

Thanks for that. I spotted it went up late yesterday afternoon.

I wouldn’t be happy spending £10k without some sort of warranty although I did send the seller a message to ask if it’s had any Haldex services and the timing belt/water pump done.
 
Last edited:
Yeah that one went up late yesterday afternoon.

I wouldn’t spend £10k without some sort of warranty, so I’d only buy from a dealer.
2nd hand dealer warranties are generally not that great to start with, with many caveats and exclusions and a very limited period. Especially on a 10 year old car.

Private sales are much cheaper, and gems can be found… look into taking your own warranty out, if that’s what you want. The money you would save on the purchase could pay for any repair, if it came to it!
 
Seller replied, doesn’t know if it’s had any Haldex services (I assume that’s a no) and it hasn’t had the timing belt or water pump done yet.

He says it’s been serviced by a Land Rover approved service center which confuses me, surely if they were doing things correctly it should have had a new timing belt and water pump 2 years ago?

It’s a minefield. At the end of the day, you make a choice and take your chances.
 
It shouldn’t have needed a new Haldex in the first place, not at 40k miles.

I noticed on the invoice it said ‘refit new Haldex and refill with oil’… now that could just be missing detail and it is referring to the diff rather than the Haldex, but the Haldex takes a particular fluid only, and it is never referred to as ‘oil’.


Ultimately, all you can do is get it checked by someone that knows these vehicles on your behalf, but I think the consensus is that it seems quite expensive for what it is.


Same year, better spec, in NI, for 3k less…

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202410195386509?advertising-location=at_cars&aggregatedTrim=&atmobcid=soc5&body-type=&colour=&fromsra&fuel-type=&make=Land Rover&model=Freelander 2&radius=200&sort=relevance&transmission=&year-to=2024
Quite a clean mot history.
 

Similar threads