Would you buy off-road equipment for your P38 if it were made available?


  • Total voters
    100
Don't think that's true. The major selling point of the Range Rover has always been it's off road ability. It has always been advertised as such - it would be disastrous for LR's reputation to dumb down their flagship.

My understanding was that the Disco was introduced to tap into the new shopping trolley/school run market for which the RR was perceived to be too expensive compared to the new Japanese competition. The fact that it was actually adequate off road was an accident of it's origins rather than a particular intention...

The original Disco was good offroad because under the skin - it's a Range Rover. The Range Rover was originally better off road than the Land rover which was still hampered with cart springs limiting wheel articulation and steering lock. Of course the Land Rover Series gained Range Rover-like suspension and became the much improved Defender.

The Land Rover product with (by far) the deepest official wading capability is the L405 Range Rover.
 
The original Disco was good offroad because under the skin - it's a Range Rover. The Range Rover was originally better off road than the Land rover which was still hampered with cart springs limiting wheel articulation and steering lock. Of course the Land Rover Series gained Range Rover-like suspension and became the much improved Defender.

The Land Rover product with (by far) the deepest official wading capability is the L405 Range Rover.

I dont do pay and play but use my P38 to go places and see things like Mongolia where you do need wading ability This video shows me paying 5 Euros to be towed across a river as i am 6000 miles from home with no backup.
river crossing in Mongolia - YouTube

but if you want to see serious river crossing watch this
Nithus.ch Russian Truckers Cross River - YouTube
 
...as for snorkel it's unlikely needed as air intake sits above engine on diesels where as defenders air intake is at the side and more likely to draw in water unless you plan to use it as a Submarine :) they have also raised the air intake for the v8 as well .... Corrected for complaints

The air intake on a 2.5DSE does not sit above the engine, it is located roughly half way down the front wing.

BTW lets get :focus:
 
The air intake on a 2.5DSE does not sit above the engine, it is located roughly half way down the front wing.

BTW lets get :focus:
Not if you remove the box and stick a k&n or similar then its above, far cheaper than a snorkel and no cutting holes on the wing ;)
 
Not if you remove the box and stick a k&n or similar then its above, far cheaper than a snorkel and no cutting holes on the wing ;)
And that will hoover up any water that splashes up under the bonnet or gets picked up by the fan and sprayed around.
 
Before thinking about fitting a snorkel, there's a problem with the plastic fan that breaks once in contact with water (usually taking the rad out in the process). I've seen this happen to 2 P38s: as soon as the water gets high enough the water will hit the fan and this will break it.
This doesn't happen to the V8s though, as those have a different fan where the outer part of the blades are all connected by a plastic rim, thus improving the overall resistance.
To overcome this problem some have fitted electric fans that can be switched off before entering deeper waters, but those usually have the problem of not starting once you come out of the water :)
 
AS somebody that has had a P38 for 8 years and drives off road quite often and has just spent 10 days driving through up to 30" of water to help the poor buggers flooded in Shepperton I would disagree with you wammers ! In 10 days of constant wading in deep wayter only once did I have a little panic when a Nissan pick up drove towards me at speed and sent a bow wave up my windscreen and the engine flutted and farted for a minute before clearing, since then the front near side hieght sensor has been playing up so is being changed thursday but cant be 100% sure that is down to the water
 
AS somebody that has had a P38 for 8 years and drives off road quite often and has just spent 10 days driving through up to 30" of water to help the poor buggers flooded in Shepperton I would disagree with you wammers ! In 10 days of constant wading in deep wayter only once did I have a little panic when a Nissan pick up drove towards me at speed and sent a bow wave up my windscreen and the engine flutted and farted for a minute before clearing, since then the front near side hieght sensor has been playing up so is being changed thursday but cant be 100% sure that is down to the water

So you repeatedly drove a P38 through deep water and it has not been relegated to a drive ornament? Get yourself down the newsagent and buy a few lucky dips - you're on a roll.
 
AS somebody that has had a P38 for 8 years and drives off road quite often and has just spent 10 days driving through up to 30" of water to help the poor buggers flooded in Shepperton I would disagree with you wammers ! In 10 days of constant wading in deep wayter only once did I have a little panic when a Nissan pick up drove towards me at speed and sent a bow wave up my windscreen and the engine flutted and farted for a minute before clearing, since then the front near side hieght sensor has been playing up so is being changed thursday but cant be 100% sure that is down to the water

You are entitled to do what you want with your car, 20 inches is max recommended though, with certain added precautions. But hey ho you carry on, not a problem for me. :);)
 

Similar threads