It's a shame the restoration projected halted. It must cost a fortunes to resurrect something like that. I guess they ran out of money. The Beeching report sounded the death knoll for lots of small rural stations and their communities but it was a logical process, those local routes often ran at huge losses. There used to be a route on the outskirts of birmingam, locally known as Lickey Bank. They reckoned the amount of passengers wasn't enough to pay for the trains fuel.

Col
 
Part of the line that the Riccarton Junction village was on has reopened recently as the Borders Railway, which goes from Edinburgh as far south as Tweedbank. Seems quite popular too, inasmuch as there were complaints about overcrowding. The post war era saw a good deal of decline of the railways independently of Beeching - there were more closures prior to his report than after. With the rise of car travel and failure of investment through the war years and thereafter, as well as rising wages, it became increasingly difficult to keep it going. Rather than a pattern of random failures, the Beeching model demonstrated how you could prune the network systematically so that there was a skeleton left that covered the UK and could be viable. It wouldn't run at a profit, but the subsidy would be politically acceptable. As numbers of passengers and freight volumes went down even further there was the Serpell report which outlined even further track losses. One option was no railway to the southwest of Bristol, for example. However, since the 1980s rail travel has become popular again and usage has more than doubled, whether you count passenger kilometers travelled, passenger journeys, footfall through stations or any other measure. So when I travel by train and there isn't anywhere to sit down, I know why!
 
Explored Riccarton junction around 30 years ago. Have walked the Waverley track bed from Newcastleton to Hawick including through Whitrope tunnel and over Shankend viaduct. The viaduct is Grade 2 listed and has received significant maintenance over the years. In 2007 the deck was waterproofed and attention paid to the arches and piers. I have travelled on the Borders Railway when on a caravan trip to Melrose and it is very modern and efficient, but why did did they not complete the restoration of the route to at least Hawick?
 
  • Like
Reactions: MJI
It's a shame the restoration projected halted. It must cost a fortunes to resurrect something like that. I guess they ran out of money. The Beeching report sounded the death knoll for lots of small rural stations and their communities but it was a logical process, those local routes often ran at huge losses. There used to be a route on the outskirts of birmingam, locally known as Lickey Bank. They reckoned the amount of passengers wasn't enough to pay for the trains fuel.

Col

Lickey is still in use as it is on the main Bristol Birmingham route
 
The lads at work are driving from isle of Sheppy to Inverness This week in 110 HT'S. Dont fancy it my self.
 
There's a lot of talk abut extending the Borders railway as far as Hawick, so maybe it will get trains again before too long.

On walking the line between Whitrope and Riccarton I was surprised how steep the hill was. The trains must have really struggled to get up the hill from Riccarton especially if the track was wet or icy, as it often would be in that part of the world.

I see some enthusiasts are talking about campaigning to get the line opened all the way to Carlisle. But that's going to be a difficult case to make as there are only a few small villages, and it is not as if tons of people from the area will be wanting to commute to Carlisle for work as it is not a big centre of employment like Edinburgh.
 
The talk of going through to Carlisle I think is fantasy to be honest. As you say there's not the population to demand it and the amount of trackbed that has been built on, viaducts/bridges removed etc. would make it very expensive to reinstate. That's before the Whitrope Tunnel is considered, a big section of roof collapsed so would need fixing. The ground is incredibly unstable there - when we harvested the area adjacent to it there were sink holes all over the place. A miracle they managed to dig a tunnel through it at all to be honest. A very interesting area though.

The trackbed from Riccarton Junction south is used as a forest road, its a damn good one too. Nice and level, and hard as nails. They certainly knew how to build things. Years ago there was talk of a railhead to take timber from Kielder/Whitrope/Newcastleton etc. to Carlisle and avoid lorry miles, but as ever the cost was prohibitive. Road transport is just too cheap by comparison.
 

Similar threads