"I did consider going to canvas, but don't like the idea in the winter"
A correctly fitted soft-top is a lot warmer than an unlined hardtop in the winter and doesn't suffer from condensation issues either.
I have had soft-top LR's as my daily driver for well over 20-years now, before that I used to remove the hardtop as & when required but gave that up and have been a happy (and warm & dry) bunny ever since. A correctly working heater plus a fume curtain and you will be nice & toasty.
A correctly fitted soft-top is a lot warmer than an unlined hardtop in the winter and doesn't suffer from condensation issues either.
I have had soft-top LR's as my daily driver for well over 20-years now, before that I used to remove the hardtop as & when required but gave that up and have been a happy (and warm & dry) bunny ever since. A correctly working heater plus a fume curtain and you will be nice & toasty.