Sam-W

Sam-W

New Member
Hi all, first time posting on here.

I bought a 2003 Face-lift Discovery 2 2.5 ES Auto at the end of last month, 87000 miles on it. After owning it for 5 days the front propshaft failed! With the prop flying around underneath as I stopped it caused damage to the gearbox sump.

I sent to a locla land rover specialist to have the rest of the vehicle checked over for peace of mind and they've come back today saying that the prop actually cracked the gearbox wear the Gasket seals with the sump. So basically looking at a new gearbox!!!

Spoken to the guy I bought it from and basically got its wear and tear and just one of those things. So want to know from you lot how long a prop should last and should it have gone at 87,000 miles?

Any help much appreciated right now as pretty gutted that I've bought a lovely truck and only got to drive it for 5 days!
 
Moved before you get the 'special' Anything Goes welcome :p

Mileage isn't really relevant, prop universal joints do wear dependant on what they had thrown at them and whether anyone's bothered to grease them.

They do usually make it quite obvious that they aren't happy well before they let go though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 8ha
Oops sorry did I put it in the wrong place.

Doesn't sound like it had been greased as he said there's no grease point... Although been reading up since and apparently there is a plug to be removed to fit a grease point.

From experience anyone know a ball park figure for a gearbox?
 
I may be barking up the wrong tree here, but you're probably not looking at replacing the gearbox but the transfer box which is where the prop shafts are connected to.
Regarding the greasing points, the screw in plug is the greasing point for the sliding joint, one on each prop shaft. You have to remove the plug and screw in a grease nipple to add grease to the joint then replace the screw in plug, at least that's the theory.
Many U/J's are "sealed for life", but how long that life is, well, that's anybody's guess. I have grease nipples on all of my prop shaft U/J's, including the "double cardon" joint.
 
OK between working and trying to sort everything out with the disco I got myself confused... The prop went and as it was spinning it hit the Gearbox right on the sump joint, cracking both faces the gasket seals to. There's a chunk missing on the face of the gearbox as well as a possible crack higher up.

So it is looking like a new gearbox... Guessing that's not going to be cheap :(
 
Sam-W said:
OK between working and trying to sort everything out with the disco I got myself confused... The prop went and as it was spinning it hit the Gearbox right on the sump joint, cracking both faces the gasket seals to. There's a chunk missing on the face of the gearbox as well as a possible crack higher up.

So it is looking like a new gearbox... Guessing that's not going to be cheap :(
Click to expand...

I see gearbox and transfer box going regularly on facebook for 400 ish as a pair. I think the transfer boxes are normally a bit more expensive than the gearbox though. Gearboxes on Discovery 2's are usually crap and not worth much unless they've been reconditioned.
 
your lucky it's a disco one. their are loads of 1.2 disco boxes around. The defender 1.4 box however....

I doubt you will be able to get a ashcroft or similar one as they want your used one back to rebuild and if the case is damaged they will charge you a additional £200 or so per box.

Personally I would look for a disco 2 gearbox and a 1.2 transfer case with a working center diff lock if you ever intend to take it offroad.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

B
Discovery Sport Need some advice please
Replies
2
Views
161
Bp112
B
N
Discovery auto gerabox issues
Replies
19
Views
1K
marjon
marjon
9
300TDI Doughnut
Replies
9
Views
804
9255 steve
9
tyregeezer
Discovery 4 Sdv6 engine removal
2
Replies
24
Views
1K
tyregeezer
tyregeezer
Pillar
Disco 3 (LR3) Discovery 3 Clicking / Rattling when under load — front prop.
Replies
3
Views
778
marjon
marjon