B

BlueCounty110

Member
Got warning about overheating transmission one week before this grenaded. Towed to the shop. This is in the US, so it’s on the drivers side. Axle shaft has been spat out.
Shop has said it needs new differential. And maybe axles. Quoted $2-3000 for parts and $3000 labour

Anyone seen this, dealt with it, fixed it? This is the wife’s car and is babied. 105,000 gentle miles. Help appreciated. Thanks
 

Attachments

  • EE373987-3F88-47B2-982E-82E1ED2A10F8.jpeg
    EE373987-3F88-47B2-982E-82E1ED2A10F8.jpeg
    146.1 KB · Views: 114
  • 81BCCF34-7DA7-4AAC-B817-93B8E073BDE5.jpeg
    81BCCF34-7DA7-4AAC-B817-93B8E073BDE5.jpeg
    149.3 KB · Views: 110
  • 220FB44E-3412-401E-8729-7D6591A9AB37.jpeg
    220FB44E-3412-401E-8729-7D6591A9AB37.jpeg
    159.7 KB · Views: 99
Not seen anything like it.

BlueCounty110 said:
This is the wife’s car and is babied. 105,000 gentle miles
Click to expand...

But would maybe ask the wife how she drive the SC, is she mechanically sympathetic?

I guess it has to come apart before you will really know.
For that to come out then I guess all the front bushes/ cvs would need a lot of slack in them.

Good luck:).

J
 
Thanks for the reply. My wife said it was making an awful noise for about 10 minutes. I asked her if it was coming from one particular wheel, thinking maybe it was a worn brake pad or maybe a stone caught in the shield. Then the sound went away. She drone about 30 minutes any stopped at a light and then it just would not move. That’s where the axle dropped out.
My wife is not at all mechanically savvy but does drive gently.
The car has been in and out of the shop for 3-4 weeks trying to sort out an ac issue. And it’s been driving fine, tracking and smooth on and off the highway.
 
It was not her fault. She was under a time pressure and was out of resources. You’re right, might have been avoided but we are where we are. Looking to forum for experience with this particular issue. Thanks.
 
So do you own a Blue County? Or, do you live in a Blue county? If you live in a Blue county is it in a Blue state or a Red state?

All this is important, you know.
 
Lol. No, first car was a 1983 blue with white stripe County 110. Full roof rack and rear ladder. Jump seats. 3.5l rover v8. Love love loved that car. Only got it stuck once, in wales. Kind farmer pulled me out of a ditch with his tractor. I was only 18 and the cost of petrol was eating me alive. I learnt how to drive that car without using the brakes - so I didn’t use so much petrol (in theory!). That was a long time ago. Now living in the States. A red/blue one. Keeps changing
 
BlueCounty110 said:
Lol. No, first car was a 1983 blue with white stripe County 110. Full roof rack and rear ladder. Jump seats. 3.5l rover v8. Love love loved that car. Only got it stuck once, in wales. Kind farmer pulled me out of a ditch with his tractor. I was only 18 and the cost of petrol was eating me alive. I learnt how to drive that car without using the brakes - so I didn’t use so much petrol (in theory!). That was a long time ago. Now living in the States. A red/blue one. Keeps changing
Click to expand...
I live in Colorado. I drive a green County ('95 RRC) in a Red county in a Blue state.

Ah, for the days when the state was Red......
 
I have a theory. The drive shaft is telescopic so if the telescopic action has siezed IMO it's possible it has pulled the snap ring from it's channel in the diff as the front suspension goes up and down.

upload_2021-11-8_22-1-1.png


upload_2021-11-8_22-1-30.png
 
It fits with my gut instinct. Perhaps that c-clip came loose and the axle shaft worked it’s way out.
Getting it towed to a garage that has apparently said they’ve seen 3 of these failures. Asked if I’d had an axle replaced because in their experience, incorrect installation may lead to this. We haven’t had that work done but the previous owner may have
Please keep your theories coming
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

proto57
Freelander 2 (LR2) Baffling (to me!) front Half-shaft/Axle Length Mystery! Too short, twice???
Replies
10
Views
874
Zorro587
Zorro587
awkwardbob
L322 Gearbox / Torque Conv Replace / Rebuild or not
Replies
15
Views
456
marjon
marjon
P
Clutch Slave cylinder leak- 2015 Defender
Replies
2
Views
680
Defenders 110
D
O
Hello from a recent first-time Landy owner!
Replies
5
Views
489
Knappster
Knappster
P
Advice needed for fixing a VM 2.5
Replies
9
Views
2K
lynall
L