sidewaysste · Jul 12, 2012

Curse you Jon! you appear to have the only good beige leather driver's seat in existence and you're selling it!
Have you any idea how long I've been searching for one?

thebiglad · Jul 12, 2012

Jongould said:
I dont agree autos aree better for towing, they use alot more fuel and the torque plate is never fully engaged till 53mph so alot of the time you are 'slipping'. Off road they are easier, not better, I prefer the control of the manuals over the ease of the autos but its all to preference...

If you want one just for towing and off road fun then look at this (its mine BTW) :

1996 LAND ROVER DISCOVERY ES 300TDi - OFF ROAD TRUCK 4x4 HIGH QUALITY PARTS USED | eBay

IF we were talking about DII TD5, then your info about auto gearboxes is innacurate as you TC lock-up in third gear at 45mph and that makes a big difference.

Jongould · Jul 12, 2012

thebiglad said:
IF we were talking about DII TD5, then your info about auto gearboxes is innacurate as you TC lock-up in third gear at 45mph and that makes a big difference.

I was on more about the 300TDi's but wasnt aware its different on a TD5, I do now tho so cheers for that infor/correction

shiftyoldscoob · Jul 12, 2012

300Tommie said:
300tdi Manual would be the way to go in my opinion.

Dr_evil said:
300tdi auto would be better for towing no ?

hifly said:
auto for both off road and towing

So what are the pros and cons of both the auto and manual?

I'd prefer the auto but if it's going to be terrible on fuel and not as good off road I may go for a manual???

shiftyoldscoob · Jul 12, 2012

Jongould said:
I dont agree autos aree better for towing, they use alot more fuel and the torque plate is never fully engaged till 53mph so alot of the time you are 'slipping'. Off road they are easier, not better, I prefer the control of the manuals over the ease of the autos but its all to preference...

If you want one just for towing and off road fun then look at this (its mine BTW) :

1996 LAND ROVER DISCOVERY ES 300TDi - OFF ROAD TRUCK 4x4 HIGH QUALITY PARTS USED | eBay

I was looking at this on ebay the other day!

Looks like a good rugged truck, whats the chassis/body like for grot?

wickford90 · Jul 12, 2012

shiftyoldscoob said:
I was looking at this on ebay the other day!

Looks like a good rugged truck, whats the chassis/body like for grot?

Why have you got a picture of jons disco and saying you have it for sale, on your website. you flog salvage??

shiftyoldscoob · Jul 12, 2012

wickford90 said:
Why have you got a picture of jons disco and saying you have it for sale, on your website. you flog salvage??

First of all I DON'T HAVE A WEBSITE and second, I just clicked on the ebay link, looked at the advert and realised I'd looked at it before....what are you getting at here???

Langers · Jul 12, 2012

I find 200 or 300 autos to be absolutely gutless when towing... most recently during our charity tractor drive, we were using a Disco 300 Auto to pull a 14 foot Ifor Williams trailer as a support vehicle.

Whilst the tractor was driving under its own power, the trailer was approximately 1,000kg. Even with this relatively light load, it really struggled, and when the tractor was loaded and the trailer weight was around 2,300kg, it barely moved at all. At one point a hill on the A303 slowed us down to 15mph!

I would suggest a 300 manual at the very least... if you're towing anything approaching 'heavy', a Td5 or a V8 would be a much better bet.

sidewaysste

Active Member

thebiglad

Well-Known Member

Jongould

New Member

shiftyoldscoob

Member

shiftyoldscoob

Member

wickford90

Well-Known Member

shiftyoldscoob

Member

Langers

Well-Known Member

Similar threads