1. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    Great thanks for your help. Valve body on EAS has had new o rings along with the compressor. It's also had a new air dryer... So think all that's left is bags, but at sub 100 a pop and easy to replace not too bothered about those. Saint v8, how many miles have yours got on them? 130k ojoon...
  2. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    Thanks for all your help. Also just found out the p38 has ''EAS pumps internal thermal switch failed so it has a external one fitted. Works perfectly well.'' what does this mean!?
  3. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    Sorry. yea it is a D1. Yea, I think P38 it is! Just got to keep my fingers crossed I don;t get a bad one! Not bothered about the interior issues as can sort everything really....just don;t want to be rebuilding the engine after a few k miles....how much do you rec it would cost to get top hat...
  4. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    thanks, which have LCF blocks? any way to tell or are all thor 4.6's lcf?
  5. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    Thanks, well I will be towing, that's why a derv gearbox worries me..... I assume if you remove the MAF you put in a MAP sensor? or does the derv already have both? I do love a v8, that;s the only other thing! Even if it is mainly for the wife to drive, especially on LPG as would probably...
  6. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    the engine may be...but what about the gearbox?
  7. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    thanks, but again i don't like the idea of a tiny highly strung diesel bm engine in a huge car....
  8. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    Thanks, still think I'll go for a v8. derv doesn't attract me in the slightest really!
  9. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    great stuff! I think I may gamble!
  10. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    great thanks
  11. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    but nothing too major? engine still strong?
  12. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    also is 1.8k for a 125kmile p38 (no lpg) worth it!? only 1 owner since new!
  13. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    thanks, p38's seem a bit of a gamble....but one I may well take! Just don't like the idea of a dual mass flywheel on a tiny diesel in a huge car especially if it's been towing and especially as i will be towing - even if my caravan is only 1.2tonne
  14. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    Yea, so many conflicting views. I know maintenance is key, but have heard that even than there is no guarantee that it will eat itself tomorrow! Is 130k on a Rv8 a lot? I know it's not for a m62b35/44 but they're German engineering!
  15. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    Thanks, so you obviously had issues with your petrol ones?
  16. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    haha, so less issues with the diesels then? the p38 has had tranny oil changed at 72k so I assume at 130k it would need it again now
  17. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    Yea, not a fan of diesel....but I suppose it is a bmw lump, just concerned about it being over worked....thought the diesels were problematic?
  18. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    haha thanks, yea I've spent a few days reading, just can't decide if it's worth the risk.....I suppose if it did breakdown my wife and baby would be safe! Is 2.5k for a P38 with 130k reasonable? Especially as a fair bit has been done....MOT history is fine to be honest, only bushed/ball joints...
  19. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    Thanks, yea a friend has had pretty much every RR out there...and I'm quite 'mechanical' and handy with a spanner...so know what to look for. Just hear so many bad stories of P38's...but much prefer the look and feel of them, if it were in my budget I'd go for an L322 I think, only as I have a...
  20. H

    P38 or D2....Can't decide! please help!

    Hi My wife and I are going to get a 4x4. It will be my wife's daily (but she doesn't drive too much as we have a 9 month old - say 5k miles a year) We will be towing a caravan and doinf a small bit of off roading. I can't decide between a D2 or P38, much prefer the look of a P38 but scared...