Hi All,

I'm wanting to replace the soft top on my Defender 110 for a more secure hardtop.

I'm torn between the CamelBac from Neneoverland and the less than half the price Truckman Canopy.

I'd welcome any for's or against's for either or both.

Why not a second hand proper LR van top, or an Ifor pig-pen?
Half the price again.

As Trewey suggests. I`ve never found Truckman tops that robust, particularly the rear door. I had an Ifor top on mine, bought secondhand for £45, not perfect but very good, takes two people 10 minutes to get off (bit longer to put on). If I`d had the spare cash I would probably have gone for LR roof, side panels and rear door - but I suspect once they had been put on I would have left them on, whereas with the Ifor I used to take it and the truck cab off for the nice weather and go back to canvas and hood sticks.