D

DeepPockets

Member
Hey everyone.
I fancy the tdv8 07 onwards I'm not shore about the command shift on the fresher gen3 thou I would be interested to hear your views. I'm thinking a good history with mileage around 90k to 120k I like the sport and the brick shape I haven't decided on shape yet. 95% of my driving will be on the road with 5% off road nothing hardcore the odd Farm track or paddock. I will be towing a trailer occasionally.

What would you guys recommend the stick auto or command shift ? Are there any other benefits of going with the fresher 09-12 Any buying tips welcome

When you think you know enough about Range Rovers to buy one, But not enough to know you shouldn't:)
 
As long as you do indeed have "Deep Pockets" @DeepPockets you will be ok. ;)
I won't touch the new stuff because they are all full of angry pixies trying to escape from ECU's and all those parts cost a mint and I am an impoverished pensioner. :D
Just remember you cannot run a champagne car on lemonade money and you will be fine. ;)
 
What little confidence I have in the reliability of the gen 3 is draining away :( maybe the x5 07-13 or Toerag would be a better choice then
I don't wanna be in the garage every 5 minutes the odd fix I can handle say 3 or 4k on repairs over 40,000 miles but if its more like 3k repairs every 10,000 miles my pockets not that deep.
 
DeepPockets said:
What little confidence I have in the reliability of the gen 3 is draining away :( maybe the x5 07-13 or Toerag would be a better choice then
I don't wanna be in the garage every 5 minutes the odd fix I can handle say 3 or 4k on repairs over 40,000 miles but if its more like 3k repairs every 10,000 miles my pockets not that deep.
Click to expand...
The X5 is no better according to reports, as for the Toerag, my experience of VAG products is not good. If you want reliable, get a Toyota Land Cruiser..
 
Datatek said:
The X5 is no better according to reports, as for the Toerag, my experience of VAG products is not good. If you want reliable, get a Toyota Land Cruiser..
Click to expand...
I had the 3.2 DID shogun a few years back it was a great tool good mpg also I like the amazon also.
In my price range The x5 3.0d 07-13 or the tdv8 07-12 seem to be a good choice for towing a 3500kgs trailer enough power to keep a steady speed on hills without to much drama. There are comprehensive warranty's that cover 12 years old and 150k for around £1500 for 3years might take the sting out owning a tdv8
 
backinblack said:
IMO they are not all bad, if you get a well maintained example then you should be ok. TBH I haven't seen many posts for the TDV8 so that should say something.
Click to expand...
been reading the cam chain tensioner can be expensive around £1800 to repair if the engines ticking on start up it seems to be common 80k to 120k other then that it seems mainly electrical or suspension related problems. I doesn't need to be the tdv8 the tdv6 would tow nearly as well I should imagine. I was just at warranty's the gold covers suspension electrical fuel system engine gearbox even bushes it might be the way to go. Thanks
 
You sound a bit disappointed?
By command shift, you mean the flappy paddles? Yep got them never use them the TDV8 gets up and goes better than you can with the 8 speed box all on its own:D. I do now and again touch 1 of the paddles by mistake and then wonder why it has not changed up;). Don’t know if it’s an option but don’t need it:D.

Right our 2011 has been a great car. It gets work if needed and always gets it’s service. Don’t know how much it has cost, but I don’t see it as excessive. It has had a few non service items but to be honest for an 11yr old car it’s fine in my book.
Don’t rush at the first shiny 1:) but there are good 1s out there so spend time looking. It will help if you are also a little handy with spanner’s and prepared to invest in diagnostics.
We got ours from Germany and drove it home here, it has done a couple of trips back to the UK, which included towing trailers back.
They eat miles effortlessly. We would not hesitate to get in it and drive back the 1600miles to the UK:).

Oh but don’t get me wrong we both enjoy a drive in the P38 or the “mudball” too:D.
Cat amoungts the pigeons :D:D.

J
 
Last edited:
DeepPockets said:
been reading the cam chain tensioner can be expensive around £1800 to repair if the engines ticking on start up it seems to be common 80k to 120k other then that it seems mainly electrical or suspension related problems.
Click to expand...

The TDV6 chain tensioner also plays up, rattling on start up. I ignored mine for 2 years, then decided to fix it, which took ½ a day, costing under £200, so why is someone wanting £1800 for what is technically an easy and cheap fix.
 
DeepPockets said:
been reading the cam chain tensioner can be expensive around £1800 to repair if the engines ticking on start up it seems to be common 80k to 120k other then that it seems mainly electrical or suspension related problems. I doesn't need to be the tdv8 the tdv6 would tow nearly as well I should imagine. I was just at warranty's the gold covers suspension electrical fuel system engine gearbox even bushes it might be the way to go. Thanks
Click to expand...
The V6 has a reputation for breaking cranks I think.
 
I had a 3.2 did. Souped up but very thirsty compared to a range rover. Towed well but incapable off-road not proper 4wd and flimsy. If that meets your standards I think you would be pleasantly surprised by tdv8 provided you don’t get a lemon.
 
You will need very deep pockets and at least a 5k emergency repair fund and yes keep away from the V6 as the cranks do indeed SNAP. Most are for sale FOR A REASON which you also have to take in to account UNLESS you know of a car which has been loved and pampered and the owner is only selling because they have either upgraded or had a change to another type of car. You get what you pay for these days too. FULL & DETAILED SERVICE HISTORY is key.
 
RangeRoller dt said:
I had a 3.2 did. Souped up but very thirsty compared to a range rover. Towed well but incapable off-road not proper 4wd and flimsy. If that meets your standards I think you would be pleasantly surprised by tdv8 provided you don’t get a lemon.
Click to expand...
My 2.8 Pajero was a darn site better than the P38 off road, LSD rear diff, lockable centre diff it would go anywhere. No crap VCU excuse for a centre diff lock, no machine gun traction control pretending to be an LSD, I would have another if I had the cash to buy a good one. It was good on fuel and the Aisin Warner auto box was trouble free unlike the ZF
 
I would consider a pajero but not another shogun. Truth is I don’t really need a 4wd at all anymore but p38 is cheap and keeps going. If I sell it now I can’t replace it with a cheap runaround with the money id get. That and the dog would never forgive me
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

ar1g3
My 1999 Ranger Rover P38 4.0 V8
Replies
2
Views
1K
ar1g3
ar1g3
richhemmings
Decisions, decisions... Purchase advice wanted!
2
Replies
21
Views
2K
richhemmings
richhemmings
ryan_1993
Buying my first Defender in the next month or so.
2
Replies
32
Views
3K
lightning
lightning
SteJ
Defender vs D2 vs D3 quandary
Replies
9
Views
2K
bongo1
bongo1
L
Buying my first car... a Land Rover
2
Replies
37
Views
2K
John S
J